Q: Thought it was the battery but could possibly be the alternator

asked by on August 06, 2016

For the past week when I'd go to get into my car I'd turn the key over and it would take a good two seconds before the car would start. When it would start, everything starts out dim then lights up and it's fine until the next day. Same thing would happen. Just the other day I had a friend look at it and the positive side on the battery was covered in corrosion. We cleaned off the corrosion, which reset everything in my car and now everything seems to be better. Went to auto zone and told the guy what it was doing before we cleaned it off and he said it's my alternator. Today I get in the car and there are no problems like there was before. Starts up fine and no dimming of lights. Any idea what it could be?

My car has 110000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Battery Replacement $247.05 - $377.49 Get a Quote
Alternator Replacement $166.62 - $1297.14 Get a Quote
Service Battery/cables $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Bad connection can be confusing. They are touching and the connection may even be tight, but electricity doesn’t care about what our eyes see. Electricity happens at the atomic level. A bad connection is a loose connection or a surface corrosion. A dirty surface can stop all electric current from flowing.

You stated you cleaned the corrosion off the battery terminal and you had positive results. This is a pretty good sign you are on the right track. My only suggestion is to do this again but buy a battery terminal cleaning tool, some battery cleaner and sealer. Once you see how the tool works, you will have a better idea of what electricity expects for it to do work for you.

Bad connections at the battery or anywhere along the connections from the alternator to the battery will result in a battery that isn’t fully charged. This will act like a bad battery and some will assume the alternator is bad. The fact is, neither of these can be accurately diagnosed without the proper conditions. Once things are as electricity expects, then accurate testing can occur.

I recommend having a certified technician, such as one from YourMechanic, service your battery cables to fix your issue.

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Sunroof leaking
Hi. The most common problem with a leaking sunroof is a clogged drainage pipe that runs down the side of the car. They usually run from both sides of the sunroof down the channel that runs beside the windshield and...
Vehicle stability control warning lights on
VSC stands for vehicle stability control system, it uses the wheel speed sensors along with the brake system to safety control, slow, or stop vehicle. This is done by it's ability to read the speed of each wheel and modulating...
My temperature gauge is going from cold to hot in a half mile. The hose going to the thermastat is HOT. Does it sound like the the
If the thermostat is open you will get the hot bottom and top hoses. Check to make sure the fan clutch is locking up and giving enough air flow across the radiator. If you have electric fan style, then is...
Stuck in reverse
Hi there, thanks for writing in. Sounds like you may need to check the shift linkage. It most likely came off at the transmission shift control arm. The plastic bushing for the shift cable falls apart over time, and then...
My water pump just dumped all its fluid. Is it safe to drive my truck if I fill it back up with water without a new pump?
Anytime there is no or low coolant in a vehicle, it can be very harmful to the engine. Low coolant can cause a seized engine or a blown head gasket. It is recommended that you have the vehicle towed to...
Car is overheating 2005 Hyundai Accent
Hello - both the overheating and the lack of heat out of the heater could be caused by inadequate bleeding of the cooling system (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/cooling-system-flush) when you put coolant in the car. To get all the air out of the...
Unusual noise after locking my car remotely
Hello there. Unfortunately, we are unable to offer you ideas as we don't see too many Holden vehicles here in the United States. We are only able to offer service and repair suggestions for cars, trucks and SUV's that are...
Well my valve cover gasket blew off as I was trying to start my van it broke into 2 parts I was just wondering why it did that it 2000 Ford Windstart
Hello - your Windstar has composite plastic valve covers, as do many engines these days. While being lighter and less expensive to manufacturer, they tend to get brittle with age and heat cycles. A momentary surge in crankcase pressure, or...
Ticking from inside like card in bike spokes
If it sound like its coming from somewhere in the dashboard, you might have a leaf or some other small piece of trash in your ventilation fan. try turning the fan speed up and see if the sound changes. Turning...

Related articles

How to Remove a Car Battery
An auto battery helps power car electrical systems. To remove a car battery, you will need work gloves, safety goggles, and basic hand tools.
How to Clean Battery Connections
Cleaning your battery connections, especially if the terminals are corroded, will help ensure the battery lasts longer and performs well.
How to Use a Battery Charger
Most Most people who have been around cars for a good chunk of their lives have experienced the hassle and inconvenience associated with a dead battery (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-handle-dead-battery-problems). Sometimes it simply happens in the owner’s driveway, which is really the best...