Q: My car's engine intermittently stalls

asked by on October 24, 2016

Has run great, but lately I'll be driving and engine will just shut off. I pull over and it starts right up and I drive away. Today it stalled on me, I couldn't pull over right away and it just started by itself. We had the fuel pump changed for a noise issue 2 1/2 yrs ago, they changed the relay and filter also. Any ideas?

My car has 185000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hello. If the engine is just shutting off then it may be an electrical issue with the ignition switch or the main relay. If the engine starts sputtering before it turns off and then it starts up again then that new fuel pump may have an issue or it may have an ignition problem. I have also had crankshaft position sensors fail on this engine and cause this.

Since it is intermittent it can be hard to diagnose. I usually install a scan tool to monitor the sensor readings when the vehicle is going to stall. This can indicate to me if it is a sensor issue or if it is related to the fuel system. If those look fine then I look further into the ignition system to see if there is a failure in the secondary ignition system.

If you need to have this intermittent stalling problem checked, consider YourMechanic, as a certified mechanic can come to your home or office to diagnose and repair this problem.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I calculate the load carried ?
It’s easy to think that your car can carry pretty much whatever you can cram inside, but that’s not actually the case. Your car has a weight limit, and it’s probably not as high as you think. This limit includes...
Car doesn't start and brakes not working.
Battery's over time especially in cold climate loses their ability to charge and they need to be tested. I would have a technician, such as one from YourMechanic, test the battery (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-will-not-hold-a-charge-inspection) to make sure it has plenty of cranking...
How do I detach the rear seat belt comfort guide?
The rear seat belt comfort guide is easy to detach. All you need to do is pinch the seat belt, and slide it out of the guide. Then return the guide to the storage compartment on the side of the...
how can you programm a keyless car with another remote
I would need to know the year make and model car. They are all different. Your best bet for this may be to find the owner's manual or have this done for you at the dealership.
I have a bad transmission and vehicle warranty is expired. I can't afford to buy a new or rebuilt transmission.
Unfortunately, your only alternative to repairing it would be to replace it with a used one. I would contact the manufacture to see if they will help with the repairs. Sometimes they will do a goodwill repair and pay for...
Can I perform the service on my own BMW?
You're right in that this car is way more complicated than a GM product. But oil change and Brake fluid change are a couple of services that you should be able to perform yourself. If you choose to do that,...
Transmission 2004 BMW X3
Hi there - this transmission (5L40E) has problems with valve body wear in higher mileage vehicles that can manifest itself in some of the behaviors you describe. This is due to hydraulic pressure not being high enough for complete, rapid...
Why does my Murano make a rattling noise only at the beginning when I start the vehicle?
Hello, thank you for writing in. Typically on cold starts, the vehicle struggles at first to lubricate all of the engine components with the thick oil. As the engine heats up the oil thins out and becomes the viscosity the...
Car won't start, it doesn't even click and i know i need my valve gasket cover replaced.
Hi There, A number of things may cause the vehicle not to start, but still provide power to the lights and accessories. It sounds like what you are describing may be related to a faulty starter relay. The starter relay...

Related articles

Is it Safe to Drive With a Faulty Knock Sensor?
Symptoms of a bad or failing engine knock sensor include slow acceleration, reduced fuel economy, and the Check Engine Light turning on.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Distributor O Ring
If your car has a distributor, common signs the o-ring must be replaced include oil leaks and engine performance issues.
How Long Does a Throttle Kicker Actuator Last?
What What happens when you turn down things in your vehicle such as the air conditioner? It slows down in a controlled manner. Just like when you decrease your speed it's not a sudden loss of power rather it is...