Q: clutch or gearbox ?????

asked by on August 05, 2016

car broke down, rac towed to garage, quote £500 for clutch but told it probably is a gear box problem, if so is it a right off ?? car purchase £1,800.

My car has 82000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Without more information, such as the symptoms you experienced, it is nearly impossible to determine the cause of your concern. Usually a clutch will wear out before the gearbox.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Steering stopped working while I was driving
A recall on Ford Escapes came out in 2014 related to this issue. The torque sensor on the steering column is the likely cause of failure as this has been the case for many other Escape owners. Unfortunately to replace...
Keys won't turn ignition past position 1.
It sounds like there is a problem with your ignition switch. The ignition switch is what your key turns. It has 4 positions. Off, accessory, on or run, and start. It must be jamming and not allowing the key to...
Brake lights work intermittently
If you had the dealer fix something and paid for the repairs, then I would take it back to them to have them fix it right. The lights coming on may be problems with a loose electrical connection, or a...
Speedometer stopped working 20km
Hi there. For your Ford E-250, it is likely that there is an issue with the instrument cluster itself, the vehicle speed sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/speed-sensor-replacement), or the wheel speed sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/wheel-speed-sensor-replacement). All of those components play a critical role in calculating...
Car won't pass inspection due to various issues with shocks, strut, coil springs. Is it better to get both sides done or only one?
Hi there: Anytime front end components are faulty, they should ALWAYS be replaced in pairs. Example; if you've got a bad driver side strut, the passenger side needs to be replaced as well. The reason for this is safety; and...
major knocking in front wheels, wheel spinning and slipping, strange feeling when turning right.
Hi there. It sounds like you have a CV joint failing. The CV joint is the flexible end of the axle shaft that allows power to flow to the wheels and still allows steering to occur. The noise you're experiencing...
My brake lights not working I changed the switch
It is possible both bulbs are burned out. The filament in each bulb should be tested with an ohmmeter. The bulbs can also be powered off the car to see if both filaments work but be wary of short circuits...
With engine off. Crankshaft pulley spins freely with belt on or off. 96 Taurus 3.0. What could cause that?
I can think of a few possible causes to this issue. 1. You are trying to replace the belt with a new one and may have got the wrong size belt. There are two different 3.0 V6 engines that are...
Where is yaw rate sensor located for 2017 Toyota camry
The Yaw rate sensor is under the front of the center console.

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Clutch Safety Switch
If your manual car is not starting, starts while in gear, or has the Check Engine Light on, you may need to replace the clutch safety switch.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Clutch Master Cylinder
Common signs include low or dirty fluid, difficulty shifting, and abnormal pedal behavior.
How to Adjust a Clutch
The clutch is a critical component in the operation of manual transmission vehicles. The clutch allows the transmission to disengage...