Bad Car Thermostat Symptoms | YourMechanic Advice

A car thermostat regulates the flow of coolant through the engine and is an incredibly important player in the operation of your vehicle’s engine. You may hear the phrase “the thermostat was stuck open or closed.” When the engine has been sitting for a while and is not warm, the thermostat will be closed. Once the engine is running and reaches a certain operating temperature, a sensor inside the thermostat will cause it to open, allowing coolant to flow to and from the radiator, decreasing the temperature so it can be recirculated through the engine again. This constant flow (in conjunction with several other cooling system components) keeps your vehicle’s engine functioning at the optimum temperature.

The opening and closing of the thermostat at the correct time are critical to maintaining proper engine temperature. In the event the thermostat happens to become “stuck” closed, there is no way for coolant to be circulated through the radiator and eventually back through the engine, which could cause the Coolant Temperature Warning Light to illuminate as well as extremely hot engine temperatures. Likewise, if the thermostat is “stuck” open, the flow of coolant is constant, it results in the vehicle’s engine temperature never reaching an optimum level of heat, creating performance problems and accelerating the wear-down of parts. There are 4 common symptoms associated with a bad or faulty car thermostat.

1. Hot Engine Temperature & Overheating

The first and potentially most alarming symptom of a bad car thermostat, or a “stuck closed” thermostat, will be the temperature gauge never leveling off within the first 15 minutes of starting your vehicle and instead slowly going from cold to too hot. This is often the first sign that the thermostat is not functioning properly. However, an overheating car could be caused by many things such as low coolant, a bad water pump, or potentially many other things. It is best to have a certified mechanic check out your car, as overheating your car can ruin your engine.

2. Low Temperature Engine

The next symptom of a bad car thermostat is when a thermostat is stuck in the open position. When a thermostat is stuck open, it constantly pushes coolant into the engine and causes a lower operating temperature. Your temperature gauge will show a needle that barely increases or remains at the lowest setting. This will reduce engine efficiency and increase emissions over time, as well as accelerate the deterioration of parts.

3. Inconsistent Temperature Fluctuations

Another sign of a bad car thermostat is inconsistent temperature fluctuations. These can occur and cause dramatic spikes and drops in temperature that eventually lead to poor engine performance and reduced gas mileage. In this case, you may see the temperature abnormally low at one point and, shortly after, climb to an abnormally high level. The thermostat itself isn’t stuck in any one position, but it will still produce false readings and cause issues with coolant regulation. This could be the thermostat sticking in one position longer than it should before returning to the open or closed position it should be at given the temperature of the coolant.

4. Thermostat Housing Area Coolant Leaks

Another symptom of a faulty car thermostat may be leaking coolant, which can occur when the thermostat does not allow coolant to flow when stuck in the closed position. Finding coolant leaks can be a bit tricky at times. This can be noticeable in a variety of locations, most commonly around the thermostat housing. It can eventually cause other coolant hoses to leak as well, often resulting in coolant leaking on the ground under your vehicle.

Thermostat replacement is a fairly inexpensive repair to make to your vehicle, preventing potentially thousands of dollars in engine damage due to excessive heat. Make sure to purchase a quality replacement thermostat if a replacement is needed to limit troubles in the future. If any of the above symptoms sound familiar to you, it may be time to have an expert mechanic diagnose your vehicle.


Next Step

Schedule Car Thermostat Replacement

The most popular service booked by readers of this article is Car Thermostat Replacement. YourMechanic’s technicians bring the dealership to you by performing this job at your home or office 7-days a week between 7AM-9PM. We currently cover over 2,000 cities and have 100k+ 5-star reviews... LEARN MORE

SEE PRICING & SCHEDULING

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Recent Car Thermostat Replacement reviews

Excellent Rating

(2,457)

Rating Summary
2,317
71
12
9
48
2,317
71
12
9
48

Greg

23 years of experience
624 reviews
Greg
23 years of experience
Toyota Camry L4-2.4L - Thermostat - Phoenix, Arizona
Attention to detail and provided clear information to his findings. Acted in a Profesional manner throuout
Ford F-250 Super Duty - Thermostat - Gilbert, Arizona
Greg is an absolute work horse. He stayed until the job was done and it did not matter that it was 10pm on a Saturday. He is a true professional.

Edward

16 years of experience
57 reviews
Edward
16 years of experience
Jeep Liberty V6-3.7L - Thermostat - Manteca, California
Mr. Stout is a very kind and knowledgeable mechanic. He answered all my questions, explained everything, and gave me trouble shooting fixes. It's called Your Mechanic and that's what I feel I have with Mr. Stout. I appreciate you sir.
Volkswagen Routan - Thermostat - Modesto, California
Edward was on time, very courteous and knowledgeable. He repaired my car quickly explaining what failed and showed me the damaged cracked part. I would use him again and recommend him to anyone

Richard

8 years of experience
12 reviews
Richard
8 years of experience
Ford Focus L4-2.0L - Thermostat - Fort Worth, Texas
He came back after I had issues and corrected the problem. It was night time and he didn't leave until he made sure it was done right. I highly recommend his service.
GMC Canyon - Thermostat - Burleson, Texas
Very nice friendly man. I was outside watching cause I like to see what's going on for future reference, if I had any questions he gladly answered them. Took a few hours to do the job but he was thorough truck's running good!

Dan

40 years of experience
1080 reviews
Dan
40 years of experience
Ford F-150 V8-5.0L - Thermostat - Buford, Georgia
Amazing. On time and completed the work super fast. Full explanation and a handshake later and my issues were solved! Will use Dan again for sure!

Need Help With Your Car?

Our certified mobile mechanics make house calls in over 2,000 U.S. cities. Fast, free online quotes for your car repair.

GET A QUOTE

Related articles

The Difference Between a Sports Car Engine and a Regular Engine
While they are similar in modern design, most everyday car engines are optimized for fuel efficiency and sports car engines for speed and performance.
How to Buy a Good Quality Engine Mount
Engine Engine mounts, also called motor mounts, are crucial to your vehicle’s proper functioning; providing a strong grip upon the engine is part of what makes the vehicle function as the damage that would certainly disable the engine if the...
How to Buy a Good Quality Engine
Replacing Replacing an engine sounds like an incredibly expensive thing to do, but when you compare the cost of repowering or replacing an engine to the cost of purchasing a new vehicle, the replacement cost becomes much more palatable, quickly....

Related questions

Rough starts and engine dies at idle
If the idle air control valve (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-idle-control-valve) or mass air sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-mass-airflow-sensor) is having problems. If the idle valve is sticking closed it can cause the engine to idle very low and rough, and will run fine if the throttle...
Engine shuts down when stopped at red lights
I don't have the repair information for your vehicle because it is so new. Since you can put the vehicle in park and start the vehicle, my guess is that you are also cycling the key. The fact that the...
What is difference between ticking and knocking?
Hey there. The engine knocking is caused by colliding flame fronts in the combustion chamber. Knocking does not stem from any mechanical fault but rather is caused by cylinder carbon deposits, low octane fuel, incorrect spark plugs, wrong engine timing...

How can we help?

Our service team is available 7 days a week, Monday - Friday from 6 AM to 5 PM PST, Saturday - Sunday 7 AM - 4 PM PST.

1 (844) 997-3624 · hi@yourmechanic.com