Q: Were my rotors really replaced?

asked by on November 02, 2017

About three months ago, I was having an issue where my steering wheel would shake while braking. I took my car in and I was told that my rotors were warped and that they needed to be replaced. I agreed to the service, and all was well for the next couple months, but now my wheel has begun to shake in the exact same way. A friend of mine who used to be a mechanic suspects that the old rotors may have just been ground down. When looking at the rotors, I can see quite a bit of rust, which seems strange for three month old rotors. Do you think it is possible that they did not actually replace my rotors? I am a young female, and I had gone in alone, so it seems that I may have been an easy target for something dishonest. I am wondering how I should precede. Should I go back to the same place and see what they have to say? Or should I get a second opinion before letting them do anything else to it?

My car has 90000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The vibration you are talking about can indeed be caused by bad brake rotors and solved by replacing them. However, there are a few parts of the job that, if done incorrectly, can cause the problem to return very soon. The mounting surfaces on the hub have to be thoroughly cleaned before installing the new rotors. The wheel nuts have to be carefully tightened using a torque wrench or similar device to ensure that the nuts are tightened evenly and not overtightened. Finally, the new brakes have to be properly "bedded in" by the technician driving the car and working the brakes hard until they are nearly overheated then allowed to cool down. Any of these steps may have been skipped by a technician who is trying to finish quickly so he can make more money. I think that is far more likely than the idea that they charged you for rotors they didn’t install.You should absolutely return to the dealer where you had the work done. Most dealer service departments will warranty their work for six months or six thousand miles some will go as long as a year. You are entitled to satisfaction with their work. In the future, if you don’t want to work with the dealer. Contact YourMechanic to have a technician come out to your home or office to service your car right there on the spot.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

SES light comes on and power drops when accelerating to 4000 RPM, after which it drives fine.
Since this is an intermittent problem it may be difficult to diagnose. The first thing I would recommend is to have a technician check your vehicle for trouble codes (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/check-engine-light-is-on-inspection) with an OBD2 scanner. If the check engine light comes...
Air conditioning stopped working
On some of these vehicles, it may be a simple cycling switch that has failed, or a more serious problem like a failed compressor. The only way to know is to have a thorough inspection of the AC system (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/heating-ac-inspection)...
Toyota Corolla vs. Scion IM
On that one, it's a toss-up. Toyota makes Scions. That was an experiment they had--"let's call these little cars Scions." They shut down Scion and now they are going to call all of them Toyotas. They are both good cars....
I'm having fuel pump relay problems.
Hey there, thanks for writing in about your 2001 Jeep Grand Cherokee. It sounds like you have an intermittent connection issue caused by a loose fuse holding tabs. The black you see is carbon where the voltage is jumping a...
Car rattle noise in the middle of console - 2006 Chrysler 300
Hey there. I recommend having an expert drive the vehicle to verify the noise so the noise can be isolated to an engine or transaxle problem. With the symptoms you describe, a rattle that only happens over 40 mph may...
My gas gauge is doing a funny little dance.
The fuel pumps (https://www.yourmechanic.com/parts/fuel-pump-assembly) are all inclusive on what they call a fuel module or assembly. These modules include a float (quite like the float on your toilet) that tells the computer and your dashboard where the fuel level is...
Question about a potential buy (2003 Hyundai Tiburon)
Just by looking at the photos, I notice the mileage is very low for the vehicles age. They say the door handle that is broke in picture is replaced. The clutch has been replaced. The seats look rough in the...
There is a shudder on take off and vibration while accelerating - 2013 Ford Focus
Hello there. Many possible faults can cause your 2013 Ford Focus to vibrate upon acceleration. From your description, it sounds like you are describing an engine misfire. Misfires can be caused by many issues, but the most common are spark...
I'm am having issues with my truck when I get on the freeway. I can't go past 40 mph on the freeway.
Hi there. The EGR (exhaust gas reciculation) Valve needs to removed and cleaned out. If the engine continues to not drive faster than 40 mph, then I recommend replacing the EGR valve (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/exhaust-gas-recirculation-egr-valve-replacement). If you need further assistance with your...

Related articles

What Is Engine Braking?
Drivers can use engine braking to slow the speed of their engine and vehicle. Engine decompression helps your brakes last longer and car stop sooner.
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Toyota Tacoma
Available Available in regular cab, access cab, double cab, and Xtracab versions, the 2012 Toyota Tacoma is Toyota’s answer to all of your compact pickup truck needs. In fact, Toyota has outsold both Ford and GM models, and the Tacoma...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're Towing a Boat
If If you’re towing a boat, the vehicle that you buy is largely going to depend on the size and weight of your boat plus trailer. Most cars, realistically, aren’t cut out for the job. We recommend a pickup truck...