Q: Switching from conventional to full synthetic oil in high-mileage vehicles

asked by on April 10, 2016

I was told that it's a bad idea to switch from conventional full synthetic oil in high-mileage vehicles. Those are a cause of gas switch taking-ins.

I actually had a discussion with an engineer at Chao and this guy was an expert. I mean, they design all else. He said that synthetic oil can’t do anything like that. But, I had to argue back at him, because I’ve seen it happen so many times. I had to disagree with him.

There’s something in full synthetic oils that they think flow better, which they admit--they flow better. But, if they flow better, they also can flow through sips of little crevices in older engines and also they can flow around the piston rings.

I had a lot of customers with old vehicles, who switched to synthetic and some of them leaked. But, a lot of them burped old oil. That’s just what happens. If you have normal, conventional oil on an old car, just keep using it. The only thing I advise to do if it burns a reasonable amount--go to a heavier weight oil plug, maybe a quart of Lucas oil additive can change the oil and that can help out a little bit. I’m not a fan of changing to synthetic on the old engines either. Even though the engineers told me that was impossible, I know it’s not true because I’ve seen it happen.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Engine knock and bad sounds on start
Since you describe your issue happening when you first start it cold, I’m assuming the noise goes away shortly after starting. When your engine is running, the internal components are literally floating on oil that is constantly pumped and supplied...
How do I turn the compass on or off?
The compass in the car will tell you which direction you’re traveling. You can turn it on or off. Press Auto on the rearview mirror for three seconds or longer to turn the compass on or off. Press Auto and...
Car rattling.
This engine rattling on acceleration may be a computer reprogram that would fix if the noise is what is called pinging or pre-ignition. The problem of the noise at idle and on acceleration may be another problem and I would...
when traveling a long distance my car will not accelerate over 60 my old Nissan did this as well. Is this a known issue?
Hello. Your particular model of Altima is equipped with a CVT transmission that will automatically put itself in a safe mode if the transmission fluid level (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/transmission-fluid-service) reaches too high of a temperature. If the fluid temperature climbs too high,...
EVAP. 2001 Pontiac Firebird
The fuel tank has a vent valve that opens when the engine is running, as the pump sucks fuel from the tank and the tank may collapse if a high vacuum is drawn. Usually this code pops up when the...
Feels like front right tire has vibration when turning left or merging lanes to the left at highway speed only. Bearings are okay
Hello, thanks for writing in. If the bearings are fine then the tires need to be checked first (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/uneven-tire-wear-inspection). If there is any uneven wear then this will occur. If the tires are all fine then the hubs need to...
Car revs when turning the key
Hello - yes, you probably need a new throttle position sensor. The symptoms you describe are classic throttle position sensor failure symptoms. I would recommend having a Throttle Position Sensor Replacement Service (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/throttle-position-sensor-replacement) completed by a mobile, professional mechanic, such...
My car has done 37,500 miles service but it only has 33,300 miles, what kind of maintenance do I need?
The maintenance reminder system (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/reset-maintenance-reminder-system) is not strictly mileage based. If 12 months elapse, without an intervening re-set, the light will come on simply because the engine oil should be changed at 12 months even if the 7,500 mileage interval...
My E350 is making a loud humming noise but it you can't hear it outside the car.
Hi There, This may be caused by a couple of different things such as a water pump (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/water-pump-replacement) that may be starting to fail or possibly an alternator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/alternator-replacement) that is beginning to go bad. Either of these will produce...

Related articles

How the Engine Lubrication System Works
Car engines need oil to work properly. Motor oil lubricates engine parts and helps prevent overheating. Changing oil on time helps your engine last.
Top 10 Ways to Extend the Life of Your Car
Every driver wants a car that lasts a long time. Make your car last longer by checking your motor oil, parking in the shade, and keeping it clean.
How to Buy a Good Quality Oil Cooler Hose (Automatic Transmission)
If If you’re seeing black stains beneath your vehicle when it’s parked, that oil slick could be caused by a leak in your oil cooler hose. The oil cooler acts as a radiator by cooling the engine oil after it...