Q: There is a noise coming from the transmission.

asked by on February 06, 2017

When my car is down shifting it makes a loud winding noise in 2nd gear only. It doesn't sound like metal on metal and as soon as it pops into first gear it stops

My car has 55000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Gears slipping when accelerating Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hi there. The noise could be coming from a clutch pack slipping with no frictions left causing a whining noise. The other thing that could cause the noise is the gears are worn and moving around too much. I recommend seeking out a professional, such as one from Your Mechanic, to help you diagnose your transmission.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Stabitrak came on
I would recommend having an engine diagnostic performed on your vehicle by a qualified technician. This inspection would start by determining what trouble codes have been stored in the vehicle's PCM. Once these trouble codes are determined the repair procedure...
Will a very small crack in my intake manifold cause major damage if I wait about 3 months to fix it?
The intake has coolant cross over tubes that directs coolant from one cylinder head to the other. If you have a crack in the intake manifold and it is leaking coolant (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/coolant-is-leaking-inspection) then when the engine is running and cooling...
I have a starter/solenoid/starter system failure
Hello, the whirring sound is a mechanical failure possibly created from an electrical fault. The starter solenoid controls power to and starter and moves a starter drive assembly into a ring gear (flex Plate). It is two gears that...
Skipping 2nd gear
Hi there. It sounds like you may have a shift solenoid or sticking valve concern. Are there any warning lights illuminated? What is the current condition of the transmission fluid? Proper testing of the shift solenoids will require a capable...
Car cuts out when changing gears from fourth to second
Hi There, Your water pump and fan belt replacement should not have anything to do with this at all. What you are describing sounds like a faulty transmission control module or speed sensor. A faulty transmission control module may cause...
Will and 03 BMW X5 radiator work in an 01 BMW X5
Hi There, Unfortunately, we would need additional information in order to properly answer your question. The BMW X5 was available with both 6 cylinder and V8 engine options, both of which came with two different radiators. You will need to...
Would like to speak to customer service to apply for Affirm for monthly payments on service?
Hi there. I have forwarded your inquiry to our sales and support team who should be contacting you shortly about your question. Thanks for writing in to YourMechanic.com.
My car won't accelerate past 25 mph. Check engine light is on, the code is for an oxygen sensor. 2002 Lexus GS300
Hello. From the explanation that you are giving me it sounds like you have a catalytic converter that is failing. When this occurs it will give you these codes and will cause a loss of power. You should have this...
I have a squeaking noise on my driver side and it also rattles as if somethings loose but if i tug the wheel to the left the sound
The noise could be brake related (including the pad wear indicator contacting the brake rotor if the pads are worn out) or suspension related. If the steering wheel shakes or vibrates that is typically due to tire imbalance although tire...

Related articles

What Does It Mean When an Engine "Knocks"?
If your engine is making a knocking noise it means there's a problem. The wrong fuel octane, carbon buildup, and bad spark plugs can cause knocking.
5 Commonly Overlooked Vehicle Maintenance Items
Brake fluid, auto transmission fluid, and coolant flushes, as well as cabin filter changes and valve adjustments, are all important services.
The Meanings of Automatic Gear Shift Letters & Numbers
A break down “PRNDL” and all its varieties, including D1, D2, and D3 modes.