Q: Is this the alternator or just the battery?

asked by on August 14, 2016

Hi this morning my car was dead and wouldn't start, so eventually I jumped it with a charger and after twenty minutes or so it died , I did this again and same thing. This leads me to think the alternator is bad because it's not recharging the battery but the date on the battery says it original to the car from 2001. So is it possible the battery just can't hold a charge anymore and the alternator is ok? Also if I put a new battery in would I be able to drive 5 miles to my mechanic without it dyeing assuming then that it is the alternator? * I checked the connections and cleaned the small amount of corrosion on the battery also before the first jump *

My car has 115000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Warning Light is on Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote
Battery Replacement $247.05 - $377.49 Get a Quote
Alternator Replacement $166.62 - $1297.14 Get a Quote
Car is not starting Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Since the battery was dead, this could be the cause of a failed alternator that was unable to maintain the battery charge. Try charging the battery first and running the vehicle. If the Charge Warning Light illuminates, there could be a problem with the alternator. In this case I would replace both the battery and alternator at the same time for the best results. If you need assistance wit this, consider YourMechanic, as a certified technician can diagnose your starting issue and replace these components as necessary. Good luck.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Carburetor needs adjustment.
Carburetors are devices that through the use of vacuum, mechanically deliver appropriate fuel amounts to an engine. The carburetor has several circuits each with its components. Some of the circuits use tiny holes to route air and fuel. As you...
Oil and coolant leak
Hi. Your vehicle can be leaking from numerous locations. I would start by performing a pressure test on the cooling system. This test uses a dedicated tool to pressurize the cooling system and pinpoint the leak. To address the oil...
motor mount replacement at home
Hello. Depending on what engine you have, the type of transmission in the van, and which mount you are replacing will determine the mount replacement procedure. You may have to drop the subframe to remove the mount you need to...
i have a 2005 gmc c5500 the heater motor comes on for 20 sec when first start truck then nothing
Hello - I suspect this may be a problem with the fan motor resistor pack. If the fan control is put in the "Max" or "High" speed position, does the fan continue to run? Does the fan only run for...
On the driver side of my car the low beam headlight doesn't work. I checked all fuses and changed the bulb, but it still doesn't work
Hey there. When you say you checked the fuses (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-check-fuses-by-rocco-lovetere) & the relays, and everything was getting power, did you check the actual outlet for power? You can use a voltmeter to test the available voltage at the bulb socket...
I need to figure out what headlight bulbs are needed for a 2016 ford Taurus
Hi there. When purchasing light bulbs for the headlights low and high beams, look at the old bulb and compare it to the new bulb. The part numbers do not need to match, such as, getting a bulb from a...
My car won't unlock
When this situation occurs, it's commonly due to a failure within the power lock module, which is what receives the signal from your FOB key and sends a signal to each door to unlock. However, it could be a simple...
2005 dodge Caravan overheated air conditioner is blowing heat one of the fans was not working so I replaced it air conditioner sti
Hello, thank you for writing in. If you have not resolve the issue(s) that caused the vehicle to overheat in the first place, then you need to start there. Do so by checking the level of your coolant, the radiator...
Brakes are making a subtle grinding sound
Hi there. Quite often a mechanic shop can miss issues like this - especially when they are trying to get cars in and out of service in their busy shops. However, if the brake pads are good and rotors have...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Nissan GT-R
Sporty, Sporty, fast, aggressive – all those words apply to the 2012 Nissan GT-R. This track-inspired car manages to bring racecar-like performance to the street, and it does so in true Nissan style. Key Features It’s tough to choose specific...
2007 Nissan Versa vs. 2007 Saturn Ion: Which One Should I Buy?
Compact cars as a class are generally meant to be commuter vehicles: with excellent gas mileage, an entry-level price point, and decent safety ratings for those who are on the road the majority of their time. These cars also make...
How to Get Nissan Dealership Certified
Nissan dealerships offer auto technician jobs to those certified through Nissan’s Service Career Opportunities for Professional Enhancement program.