Q: I torqued the axle nut on my 1996 BMW 328i to the spec of an M3 and want to know if I may have damaged the axle in some way.

asked by on March 19, 2018

To whomever this may concern,

I have been working on overhauling the rear right side of my car (axle, bearing, rotor, caliper, brake shoes, etc.) for the past few weeks. Last night I was finishing up when I over-torqued the axle nut to the spec of an M3 instead of the spec of a 328i (221 ft/lbs vs 184 ft/lbs). Only when I double checked the torque specs this morning did I realize my mistake. The car was driven 50 ft up the parking lot to another space very very slowly (slowly because my breaks weren't bled and I was using the parking break to stop).

If fixing this is as easy as replacing the axle nut with a new, properly torqued one I wouldn't mind. My biggest worry is that the new axle threads or parts of the hub/bearing get damaged. If damage is probable, would I be able to tell if I remove the axle nut and look at the axle threads? Or am I over-worrying about something with an easy fix? Thanks in advance for your help on diagnosing the degree of my mistake.

Best, Marvin

My car has 150000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Hi Marvin. Thanks for contacting us today. The main cause of over-torquing is using an impact or air wrench. However, the majority of damage occurs when the torqued component is in use, develops heat then cools. In your situation, catching it before using the vehicle should not cause damage - especially at the range you’ve described. If the stud or bolt in question was aluminum, that would be more of a concern. You should be ok.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the flash-to-pass feature?
The flash-to-pass feature lets you briefly turn on the high-beams. To use this feature, pull the turn signal lever (which protrudes from the left side of the steering column) towards you, then immediately release.
Car vibrating when accelerating.
From my experience with your type of vehicle, it sounds like you may have some worn control arm bushings. These bushings are made of rubber and are meant to isolate the noise of your suspension from the body of your...
Windshield wipers don't work
Hi there. If the wipers stopped working on all speeds then the wiper motor may have failed. I typically start with checking the voltage at the motor to see if it is present. If it is not then there may...
Car cranking, but not turning over
Hello, there are many possible reasons for a no-start. Your description is a little confusing since you say it crank but it doesn't turn over. In auto terminology, "crank" and "turn over" have the same meaning. If what you are...
There is a ca clunk sound when shifting into reverse.
Hello. The technician you had look at the vehicle is correct. The symptoms you describe are that of faulty engine mounts, the torque mounts more specifically. This is a common issue on your particular vehicle and can be resolved in...
High Pitched Squeal
From what you described, this problems sounds like it is likely due to a worn serpentine belt. You may need to have your belt replaced to get rid of the high pitched squeal. If you would like help replacing the...
I just replaced my radiator and it's leaking transmission fluid.
Hi there. The transmission cooling lines are very tricky on a Mitsubishi Eclipse. Sometimes cross-threading or not properly tightening the lines can cause them to leak while, in some instances, a rubber o-ring inside the line might be pinched. The...
How often do you replace a catalytic converter?
This would all depend on the quality of the catalytic converter and whether or not the engine is running rich. If the catalytic converter installed was not of OEM quality, this can be part of the reason that it did...
1996 f350 with 351w want to swap to 12 valve Cummins, how do I do it legally?
Hi there. To be honest, this would require you to replace not only fabricate new motor mount brackets, but completely swap out engine, transmission, drive shaft components. The V-12 is a much longer block so everything behind it would also...

Related articles

5 Essential Things to Know About Luxury Vehicles
There’s There’s something to be said about the looks and offerings of luxury vehicles, but appearances can always be deceiving. If you’re considering buying a luxury car, there are a few things you need to know before you make your...
How to Use a BMW With Comfort Access Technology
The The BMW comfort access technology was introduced in 2002 as a keyless remote system that uses sensors to detect where the owner is in proximity to the vehicle within 1.5 meters (about 5 feet), allowing him or her to...
Top Automotive News & Stories: October 1-7
BMW i5 images leak, an ultra-lux Jeep, hydrogen-fueled Colorado ZH2, Fisker's electric future, record plug-in sales, NHTSA Road to Zero, and more.