Q: I replaced all pads and rotors. There is pulsating /grinding noise when I brake. Is it a reluctor ring or sensor?

asked by on November 03, 2016

I need to know if I need a reluctor ring or sensor. My car pulsates and grinds when stopping. I dont have a abs light on in the car and have had all the pads and rotors changed. The shop said I would have to hook it up to a machine but if its a ring it wouldn't show because there is no codes for that. And if it was a censor I'm assuming the abs light would go off unless its burnt.I feel like I'm diagnosing my own problem. I need someone to steer me in the right direction. Already paid for breaks I didn't need.

ABS Light is on Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote
Brake Caliper Replacement $222.57 - $1200.97 Get a Quote
Brake pedal is pulsating Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Pull the fuse for the ABS system to disable it and then test drive the car (don’t forget to re-install the fuse later).

If the pulsating/grinding noise remains that means the ABS system has nothing to do with your problem. The reluctor ring is not an item that can wear out. Consequently, only visual inspection of the ring is required to determine if there is mechanical damage (such as missing teeth) or if the ring is mispositioned.

The sensors can be tested with any portable scope (no "machines" are required) and in any event, if a sensor did fail assuming your ABS light is not blown out, the warning light would have alerted you to the failure.

If the noise is from the service brakes, just because they put new rotors on doesn’t mean anything. Rotors can be warped right out of the box (i.e., defective) and even if they were brand new they can essentially be destroyed (warped) if a novice and/or untrained individual does not mount the rotor properly on the hub (using a tightening sequence and a calibrated torque wrench and then checking for run-out. If run-out exceeds .002 inches the rotor has to be re-indexed if possible or shimmed on the hub).

The mounting is critical, if the run out on the rotor exceeds the thickness of ONE human hair, your brake pedal will pulsate a lot. So depending on what the rest of the diagnostic reveals, your rotors might have to be measured to rule that in or out.

An additional issue is the calipers and the condition (freeness) of the sliding pins on the torque plate. If the calipers on your car are the original ones, and they have never been rebuilt, they should have been AUTOMATICALLY recycled (discarded) and replaced with Toyota rebuilt calipers (available at any Toyota dealer; do NOT use aftermarket in this application).

After a point (16 years is plenty of time) calipers have the potential to stick due to the dreadful operating conditions at the rotor. Imagine being cooked time after time at 500 degrees while being bathed in a corrosive salt bath. The reason calipers, even 16 year old ones, are not recommended for replacement by "shops" is simply because the shop has already padded the labor charges to make more profit, and once done, obviously the economics are such that nothing is left in the budget for you the consumer to buy what is indeed an essential part of the job, that is replace the calipers if they are 16 years old! If the shop charged a reasonable labor rate, you could afford the calipers. What do they care? They get paid regardless of whether the job is done properly or or not from a technical perspective.

At this point, you need a certified professional to get to the bottom of this. Consider having a mobile diagnostic, which in your circumstance will also represent a useful second opinion, in regard to your braking system pulsating.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What features can I customize through the Vehicle Customization feature?
Using the Vehicle Customization feature, controlled by the Driver Information Center controls, 4 buttons located on the left side of the instrument panel behind the steering wheel, is used to customize the settings of various systems throughout the truck. Here...
Do the rotors needs to be replaced with the brake pads?
All Mercedes manuals recommend replacing the brake pads and rotors in sets. The rotors cannot be resurfaced due to material used in the rotors. The rotors are made of softer materials than most vehicles and wear more and should be...
Can I get a high output alternator for my car for putting in a bigger amplifier?
Hello. There are aftermarket alternators on the market that you should check the internet for kits for this vehicle so you can install the larger amp. You may find that this large of an amp may require a second battery...
Would there be something wrong with a 2005 Chrysler 300c if the gear doesn't shift till about 5-6 RPM?
This can be caused by a few things such as low transmission fluid (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/transmission-fluid-service), a transmission vacuum leak or a faulty transmission control solenoid. Modern automatic transmissions use pressurized hydraulic fluid to change gears. Every time a gear change is...
Car stalling while driving - 2006 Pontiac Grand Prix
Hi there. The P0033 OBD-II error code (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0033-obd-ii-trouble-code-turbo-charger-or-supercharger-bypass-valve-control-circuit-deleted-by-john-nelson) is a generic code that typically indicates a problem with the Turbocharger or Supercharger Bypass Valve Control Circuit. In most cases, the reason the code is triggered is due to a vacuum...
What does the PCV valve and hose look like and where are they located?
Hi there. The PCV valve for this particular model is built into the hose assembly. The hose is a larger hose that connects to the intake plenum and runs to the rear valve cover, you can't miss it as it's...
Stalling on acceleration when I put my foot on the gas pedal?
Hi There, It sounds like you are describing the symptoms of a failing throttle position sensor. The throttle position sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/throttle-position-sensor-replacement) monitors the throttle position of the throttle plate inside the throttle body in relation to your foot position on...
mercedes don't start when cold
Hello, thank you for writing in. Vehicles often have a hard time starting when the weather is cold. There is not much you can do besides stay on top of your regular maintenance. With that being said, make sure your...
Throttle body cleaning
The only approved cleaner for the throttle body is "throttle body cleaner" (be sure not to use carburetor cleaner). The carcinogenic (and other notable adverse health effects) of this (or any cleaner) are linked to the dose. If you set...

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Speedometer Cable
Common signs include the speedometer needle wavering or not moving, squealing noises behind the dashboard, and the Check Engine Light coming on.
How Long Does a Hydraulic Brake Booster Last?
Being Being able to brake at a moment’s notice is important and can help to save you from an accident. A car’s braking system has so many different components and keeping them all in good shape is not an easy...
How Long Does a Mass Airflow Sensor Last?
The The right amount of air and fuel in your engine is a vital component in keeping the engine running as it should. Making sure that all of the vital components of the air and fuel system are running at...