Q: Generally speaking, would a cracked crank shaft pulley be replaced during a full engine rebuild?

asked by on July 10, 2016

We had our engine rebuilt and when we brought it home the mechanic said we needed to replace the crank shaft sensor. We did so and about a month and a half later the Jeep wouldn't start and idle. After testing found that cylinder 2 was dead and the rest had low compression. After this the computer ended up shorting out and then they blamed that on an "improperly seated crank shaft sensor". When we pulled the engine and all of that a part, we found the crank shaft pulley was cracked along the inside and that cylinder 2 was bright and sparkly silver color while the rest were all black. According to the shop that rebuilt the motor, this happened to the cylinder because gas was let in there from a faulty sensor. So I don't know if this is possible or true but my theory is much different.

My car has 209000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hello there, this seems like a rather complex situation with everything that has happened. I will answer this the best I can with the information given. The crankshaft sensor could cause the vehicle to not start, but if it does, it would idle erratically. The ECU uses the information from the crankshaft and camshaft sensors to fire the proper cylinder and the proper time. The computer may become damaged if there is a short in the wiring such as with the crankshaft sensor. If a cylinder is not firing but the fuel injector is still spraying fuel into the cylinder, it can cause what we call a fuel wash. The fuel in this case is unburned and will clean the cylinder resulting in the clean cylinder you have noticed. Either the cracked crankshaft pulley or the crank sensor or the computer could of caused this misfire among other issues. It sounds like a few different issues contributed to the engine failing. With everything going on, you may want to have a professional inspect the car firsthand to verify what happened and advise on how to proceed in this situation.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does the color of the engine start/stop switch mean?
Cars equipped with the smart key system and a push-button start have a colored light on the start/stop button. This light can provide you with a lot of information about the condition of the system itself. Here’s a quick rundown:...
Dashboard draining battery
First, let's determine if the engine is cranking. If the engine is not cranking it could be any one of these issues: weak or defective battery, bad battery cables, ignition switch, starter motor, seized or hydrolocked engine, or other wiring....
I hear a grinding noise when turning left
You should have a brake inspection performed to verify the thickness of your brake pads; you may need new brake pads and/or rotors. An inspection from a qualified technician, such as one from YourMechanic, can investigate the cause of the...
RPM sticking during acceleration on a 2004 Fusion
That thing has an electronic throttle. It's called "drive-by-wire." Basically, you are actually stepping on a computer mouse and the computer mouse sends electricity to the computer. The computer then sends the electricity to the throttle stepper motor and the...
Speedometer jumps car moves slow
If your speedometer needle or gauge is jumping up and down while the vehicle is moving at a slower speed, two possible issues may have occurred. Either the whole instrument cluster has failed at some point preventing the speedometer from...
Car wont go into gear - 2010 Ford Mustang
Hi and thanks for contacting YourMechanic. The issue with the gear shifter is the shifter itself. The shifter has broken and is not engaged with the synchronizers within the transmission. This is why the shifter is very smooth and moves...
Air hissing sound - 2002 Kia Spectra
Hi - air hissing sounds (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/hissing-sound-by-jimmy-f) like you describe could have several causes. A leak in the engine intake system, a leaking power brake booster (brake pedal harder to press?), or something rubbing on the engine accessory belt can all...
I failed a smog check with the codes PO171 & PO174, saying the system is too lean on the bank 1 & 2. Can you tell me what the problem is?
Hi there. When the two codes P0171 (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0171-obd-ii-trouble-code-system-too-lean-bank-1-by-andrew-quinn) and P0174 (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0174-obd-ii-trouble-code-system-too-lean-bank-2-by-blake-griffin) come up for a lean system on both banks of your engine, then either all of the fuel injectors are not working properly or your fuel pressure has dropped....
My car stalls when driving battery light comes on before it stalls and then has a hard time starting ...seems like it has no power
Hello, thank you for writing in. There may be an issue with the alternator or the battery. The first thing you can do is scan the vehicle for diagnostic codes. The check engine light is on because a code has...

Related articles

How to Buy a Good Quality Ignition Coil
Ignition Ignition coils operate in a very similar fashion to a transformer; with a 12-volt power source that produces output current simultaneously to an input current that’s being applied. By creating an efficient magnetic field, the force of the electricity...
How to Choose a Jeep Grand Wagoneer
Due Due to a recent surge in popularity, the Jeep Grand Wagoneer is making a comeback. Since the vehicle was manufactured only throughout the sixties, seventies, eighties, and the early nineties, most Jeep Grand Wagoneers are no longer on the...
How to Tell the Difference Between LSD and ULSD Fuel
Low Low sulfur diesel (LSD) was replaced with ultra-low sulfur diesel (ULSD) in 2006 as part of an initiative to substantially lower the emissions of particulate matter in diesel (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/5-essential-things-to-know-about-owning-a-diesel-car) engines. The initiative began in the European Union and later...