Q: Why won’t my battery hold a charge if it’s new?

asked by on November 05, 2015

My 2009 Honda Pilot with 45,000 miles has a problem keeping the battery charged. The battery will just be dead some mornings. Other times, it is so weak that the motor barely starts. The alarm is sometimes involved. I have replaced the battery twice now and this problem is getting exhausting! What should I do?

The problem you are describing is what we call a parasitic draw on the battery, which is an excessive draw that prematurely kills the battery either over a certain amount of time or overnight. In order to test the system draw, an amp probe on a positive battery cable is used to see if more than 50 milliamps are being drawn.

There are two potential issues which may be killing your battery. The first, the A/C relay may stick closed after shutting off the engine, which would draw excessive amps and cause your battery to die in 8 or more hours. Replace the A/C relay to fix this. The second problem is that the sunroof module is causing excessive draw, killing the battery with in a week or two. Reprogram the roof module at the dealer to correct this. Another problem could be that the body control module is not going to sleep after shut down, which may be due to the door ajar switch or other issues. A thorough diagnostic would be needed to uncover what exactly is keeping the module awake. A trained mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, can perform a battery inspection to determine why your battery is will not hold its charge at your home or office.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Brakes squeak going in reverse
This is a problem that may not be able to be fixed. The noise is from the brake pad material metal (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/why-do-brakes-squeal) in the pads squeaking on the rotors when you go in the opposite direction of the pad's normal...
My car just spatters and shuts down while driving...I have changed gasket, fuel pump, spark plugs but it still failing.
Hello and thanks for your question. With your vehicle cutting off during driving and sputters when driving there could be a few things wrong. I don't know what gasket you replaced, but replacing the fuel pump and spark plugs are...
Car Not Starting - 2013 Dodge Charger
Hey there. I would start with testing your battery (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-check-a-car-battery) and alternator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-test-your-alternator_2) with a multi-meter. Good batteries hold a charge of 12.6 volts or higher. If the battery is low, try to jump start it. If this starts your...
My car is smoking but not overheating, and burns a lot of oil.
Hi and thank you for contacting YourMechanic. There are two things to look for. First is the exhaust smoke blue? If it is that indicates that the piston rings are worn and the engine needs to be rebuilt. Oil is...
My car won't shift out of 1st gear. I replaced the engine with one from a Saturn, now it won't shift up.
The vehicle speed sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/speed-sensor-replacement) (VSS) has failed or lost power to the transmission and computer system. The computer needs to recognize the road speed to perform an up shift. Check the VSS to make sure the harness is plugged...
I can't find a CV axle
The Integra axle may not work with your hubs, and you could end with the same concern. If the original transmission will bolt correctly to the Integra engine, then the civic axles will work. However, with mismatching transmission and hubs,...
Car stopped while driving , steering wheel hard to turn and car won't start . Gas on empty
Hello, It sounds like the vehicle may be out of fuel. If the engine has shut down (regardless of the reason), the power steering will no longer work, which is why the steering was hard to turn. I would recommend...
2010 BMW 750i will not engage into park goes to neutral
Your car has an electronically controlled transmission that has had a series of issues. So it could be a transmission problem, or it could a control issue. .Whatever the problem, a technician with the right scan tool should be able...
2013 nissan altima jerks when stopping or slowing down.
Hi there. If the jerking occurs while pressing the brake pedal, it's likely that you have an ABS sensor failure or that your front brakes pads are worn out and need to be replaced. It's also possible that your front...

Related articles

The Top 8 Things That Will Drain Your Car Battery
Your car battery could keep dying from a variety of reasons such as age, a bad alternator, human error, and more.
How to Check the Voltage of a Car Battery
There are few things more frustrating than discovering that your car won’t start because the battery is dead. A mechanic can measure...
The Best Used Cars to Buy to Maximize Resale Value
A A car is not an investment. An investment, by definition, increases in value. A car is a necessary purchase, and it will never appreciate in value, with the possible exception of classics and antiques. So, as a used car...