Q: Thinking of buying a different car. I found one online and took it for a test drive. It has a few concerns. Is it worth investing?

asked by on February 06, 2017

I'm interested in purchasing a vehicle. It's a 5 speed '98 Impreza. It has a few issues and I'm not very good with cars. He listed 3 concerns about the vehicle: 1. Clicking sound when driving and can be heard when driving. Doesn't seem to get louder with speed but it makes no noise when at idle. He says it might be a wheel bearing but isn't sure. 2. He says one of the struts in the rear is in need of replacing. I'm not sure what it is but I didn't notice anything out of the ordinary when driving. 3. Shifter has excessive play when in gear. It goes into gear just fine but wobbles a lot from side to side. I also couldn't seem to put it in the right gear each time I try shifting from 2nd to 3rd. As I take the shifter and move it forward, it goes to 1st. I have to move it to the right a bit to put it into 3rd.

My question is, does this look like it will be a very costly investment? Any possible ideas for which part (s) may be faulty? Is it even worth it? It would be a daily driver. Thanks

My car has 178000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Hi there. With the problems that you have mentioned, this could be an expensive fix, depending on what is wrong with the clicking sound and what is wrong with the transmission. The clicking sound is more of a CV Shaft joint failing and the transmission shifter either has a broken shift collar or the fork is broken on the rail of the shifter. The vehicle could be a good investment if you are planning on replacing the parts yourself, but if you are wanting to have a shop replace the parts, then the repairs will be costly. I recommend looking for a vehicle that does not need a lot of maintenance right away. If you need further assistance with your car choice, then seek out a professional, such as one from Your Mechanic, to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the power windows?
Your car is equipped with power windows. Each door has a control for its own window, while the driver position has controls for all four, as well as the window lock button. The driver side window also has a one-touch...
TPMS light is on. What does that mean?
Hi there. The TPMS light can come on for several reasons. Most of the time it comes on for low tire pressure. You need to check the tire pressure and make sure that all four, including the spare are filled...
AC compressor not coming on
Your compressor is most likely not coming on due to your air conditioning system being low on refrigerant. When this happens the computer does not let the compressor activate to prevent damage. The refrigerant slowly leaks out over time and...
Will go in reverse not forward what are the choices I have
If the fluid level is correct, and there are still no forward gears, there is most likely a problem inside the transmission. Typically, if it were something outside of the transmission, both the forward and reverse gears would be affected....
Lower ball joint
Hi there. When replacing the lower ball joints to your vehicle, you will need to press down on the ball joint to remove it. Before trying to remove the ball joint, check to see if there is a snap ring...
Why does the the engine sound loud when you first start it up? Then it quiets, but as you drive you can still hear it on a Echo
Hi there. That is a very interesting situation you have with your BMW. To be honest, I've never seen tire valve stems cause any type of noise; especially under the conditions you're describing. It is possible that you may have...
P0170 and P0173 codes. Mercedes-Benz w203 V6 C230 2006 year sport-sedan
You're right to check for vacuum leaks. Low fuel pressure could also be a problem. P0170 and 173 refer to fuel trim on bank one and bank two. The ECU has detected that the engine is running lean, and is...
Can 16 inch tires / rims be used on a car that came stock with 17 inch tires / rims?
Hi there - the answer is "possibly". There are 4 technical questions which must be affirmatively answered first to go forward with this swap. First - do the wheels you acquired have the same bolt pattern as your stock wheels...
SOME ONE BROKE INTO MY 2010 DODGE CHALLENGER. THEY PUT A SCREW DRIVER IN THE KEY HOLE AND HAMMERED IT IN I ASSUME. I CAN NO LONGER
Sorry to hear about that. Yes, that is repairable (replaceable) and a certified mechanic from YourMechanic will be glad to perform the repair during a mobile visit. The relevant service to request is door lock cylinder replacement (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/door-does-not-lock-or-open-inspection). Once on...

Related articles

How a Cable Clutch System Works
If If you drive a car with a manual transmission, you know that to get your car moving, you depress the clutch pedal, choose a gear, and then give the vehicle a bit of gas. But have you ever wondered...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Strut Assembly
Common signs include knocking noises when driving over bumps, a bumpy ride, floating front end, and uneven tire wear.
How to Drive Your Manual Transmission Car With a Broken Clutch
If you drive a car with a manual transmission, there will likely come a point in time when the clutch wears out (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-long-does-a-clutch-last)...