Q: Stripped lug nut/unable to change tire

asked by on June 25, 2017

I had a blow out on my back right passenger side tire. I had my insurance send out a repair man to come fix the tire. The man worked on it for about 20 mins, then said he was unable to change the tire because one of my lug nuts was stripped. Prior to this blowout, all of my lug nuts were fine. So the repairman states that I have to have it towed. So he ends up towing it 65 miles to my house and I pay $250. The next day, I take it to the shop and they are unable to get it off because of the same issue. Again, had two other repairmen look at the car and they use automatic lug removers, still no luck. I contacted my insurance to file a damage claim on the repairman who damaged the lug nut, but they said they can't send a rental to me until they follow up on the company they sent to me which is bs. Questions: how can I get this one lug nut off so I can change this tire?? Is there something I can buy from autozone or Walmart that can act as a grip to take this thing off?? Please help me.

My car has 210529 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Tighten Wheel Lug Nuts $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hello, thank you for writing in. Locking lug nuts would cause every wheel to require a special socket in order to remove the tire. These are often aftermarket, but if you have a set on the car, this may have been the cause of that particular lug nut becoming damaged. With that being said, if you simply have a damaged lug nut, there are a few tricks you can do in order to remove the wheel. One would include welding on a socket in order to be able to grip the lug nut. Not many technicians are equipped or willing to do this however, particularly when insurance is involved. A second includes tapping a socket onto the lug nut with a hammer in order to jam it onto the nut. This WILL damage the wheel, the nut, and your socket. It can also break the socket, and under pressure that metal shrapnel will fly into the air which is incredibly hazardous. Again, this is why most technicians are not willing to do it. Double check that you are not dealing with a locking lug nut (possibly by making sure you can remove another one of the tires with a normal socket), and then proceed to find a technician who is confident they can remove it. To have one of our technicians assess the issue, contact our service department.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car won't start, even with jumpstart.
A long period of sitting can be harmful to a vehicle's battery. Your battery sort of learns a pattern of draining slightly and being charged back up again by the alternator. If this does not occur for a long period...
Car fans stopped working
The fans on your car work together together and get the power and control from the fan module on top of the radiator. If one fan is working but not the other then that fan motor would need to be...
2004 Honda Civic LX. The entire electrical system pulsates with the engine. New battery and had the alternator tested.
Hi there. From the description you have provided, your vehicle's pulsating electrical system is an unusual problem. The main relay (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/main-relay-computer-fuel-system-replacement) is not likely to cause your vehicle's electrical issue. The fact you have been driving your vehicle this way...
Heater only works on high. Heat is not hot.
If your heater only blows when the setting is on high, this may suggest that you have a faulty blower motor resistor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/heater-blower-motor-resistor-replacement). The highest speed setting may still work because in most cars in the highest fan speed settings...
windshield wiper missing spots
If the missing spots are within the area that is actually swept by the moving wiper blades, that means the spring tension on the arm is inadequate. Sometimes the spring that provides the tension will get rusty and sometimes the...
The ABS light came on dashboard
Hello, The ABS light refers to your anti-lock braking system which is controlled by a module and wheel speed sensors at each of the four wheels. This may be an issue of a faulty ABS control module or possibly faulty...
My lock indicator light is flashing.it had never done this before.why would it be flashing now?
The theft system is active and may have an issue with the key or the system. You will need to try your second key to see if light goes out? If it still stays lit then you will need to...
2008 Crown Victoria police intercepted forward gears slipping but reverse works perfectly?
It is possible that some internal damage may have occurred on your transmission. I would recommend having the major components of your transmission inspected by a qualified transmission specialist to determine the exact cause of this issue.
Changed the oil sensor an the car sounds an drives fine but when i rev an take my foot off the gas oil psi drops almost to 0
Although there is some variance across engine types, minimum oil pressure at idle is typically fairly low to begin with, typically in the range of 4 to 10 PSI. If idle speed drops below normal, so will oil pressure. Gauge...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re an Interior Designer
As As an interior designer, you need to transport a great many different items, including fabric, paint and wallpaper samples and sometimes even furniture items. You probably don’t handle overly large loads very often, and when you have to, you’ll...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Have a Tiny Parking Space
In In many cities parking spaces come at a premium, so you only want to purchase one small space. This small space will end up dictating what vehicle you purchase, so we’ve rounded up some great candidates. Must-haves Arm yourself...
Is it Safe to Drive With a Tire Bulge?
Tire bulges are caused by hitting road debris or when you overinflate your tires. Replace bulging tires right away to stay safe on the road.