Q: Starter / or battery ?

asked by on September 20, 2016

How likely is a mechanic to replace a starter with a Toyota part vs some other brand?? I am getting varied answers to this...but mostly from what I am told and what I read online is that if my car is able to be jumped (easily) with cables...no fails on that...that my problem is NOT the starter (or it would not be able to be jump started)....is this TRUE or NOT??? Please help

My car has 100000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Battery Replacement $247.05 - $377.49 Get a Quote

This is correct. If your car’s starter was failing, it would not be able to be jump started since the power from being jump started is still eventually sent to the starter via jumper cables rather than your car’s own battery. Sometimes when the battery is very weak or there is a problem with the starter relay, the car will make a clicking sound or just simply not crank which is often times misdiagnosed as a bad starter. If your car is able to be started with jumper cables, your problem is not the starter, but most likely a weak battery. I would recommend taking the battery into your local auto parts store to have it tested. Then if you realize this is the case, a certified technician from YourMechanic can come to your home or office to replace your battery at your convenience.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Problem with air suspension.
The front air bags or air lines may have a leak or the height sensor is defective. The most likely cause is the height sensor is defective.
Service Engine Soon and ABS light on. Won't pass smog check.
The problem may be the reluctor wheel. This is what the sensor reads as the wheel turns. If one of the teeth on the wheel are damaged or missing, the sensor will not be able to determine speed. The problem...
Tie rod loose
If one tie rod is loose, then more than one may be loose in the front end. The CV joint boot is most likely torn, causing the grease to leak. The loss of grease will cause the joint to go...
No gas getting to the engine
The easiest thing to check is to listen to the fuel tank when the engine is cranked to see if you hear the fuel pump run. If you hear it run, then check the fuel filter for it being clogged....
My car crank but won't start
Hi, thanks for writing in. If you hook up a scanner, it should give you codes. You can just have the key on the engine off. If you are not getting any output of codes, then you may have a...
What does it mean when there is the letter I showing on the control dashboard panel inside a gas pump symbol
Hi there. After reviewing the 2016 Jeep Grand Cherokee owner manual (www.jeep.com/download/pdf/manuals/2016-Cherokee-OM-2nd.pdf), the only lights that I could find that is similar to the one you've described are the TPMS (low tire pressure light), Low Fuel warning light, or the...
Service Light is on!!!
Hi there. If you are looking for an explanation of what the codes mean, you can use our search tool (https://www.yourmechanic.com/advice), as we have multiple articles written about OBD-II trouble codes. If you're looking to find a way to download...
I just bought a 2007 Hyundai Santa Fe with the 3.3 v6. I had the oil changed snd 5.5 arts didn't show on stick. 6 barely did.
Hello, thank you for writing in. The vehicle should take 6 quarts of oil with a new filter. Make sure the dip stick is fully inserted and getting a proper reading. Also make sure you are checking the level after...
Hey I wash wondering if I can put a twin turbo in my chevy cruze LT 1.4turbo
Hi Miguel. I've always believed that anything is possible with fabrication. However, fitting a dual-turbo charged system on your OEM engine would require a tremendous amount of upgrades, ranging from intake changes, exhaust, as well as internal combustion changes like...

Related articles

How Does a Starter Motor Work?
When you turn the key in your car’s ignition, the engine turns over and then cranks. However, getting it to crank...
4 Essential Things to Know About the Keys to Your Car
Car Car keys are an essential part of your vehicle and there are a few different types of them depending on the make and model of your vehicle. Car keys will allow you to get into your vehicle, start your...
How to Charge a Dead Car Battery
The battery in your car can go dead for any number of reasons leaving you stranded. It can be low from lights being...