Q: Rough Idle in park and neutral runs smooth in gear

asked by on June 24, 2016

Earlier this year car started running rough.. took it to the dealership, who said the plugs were fine. Took for an oil change.. they changed oil, air filter topped the fluids.. and said 2 codes camshaft sensor, and P0456 small EVAP leak. we changed the camshaft sensor, car ran fine.. Until a couple weeks back it started idling and running rough.. I cant pull any codes.. dont have the money to take it to a mechanic.. troubleshooting as much as I can. Checked the gas cap... its not that. it starts.. it drives.. idles super rough.. smoothes out in gear. Ac works fine. not sure what else to look for.. no hissing under the hood..any suggestions? anything helps!!! Aloha

My car has 110000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car idle is rough Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

You will need to have the engine checked to see if you have codes to assist with diagnosis before looking at getting the ECM reprogrammed for the rough idle at a dealer. I would suggest having a certified technician diagnose the rough running to make sure it is not an engine vacuum leak or an ignition problem. If the Check Engine Light is on, you may have a problem that needs diagnosis or you will just need the ECM reprogrammed. The injectors may need to be cleaned also to help the engine run smoothly out of gear. The engine tends to go real lean out of gear and can cause the rough idle. This is normal but the rough idle is not and dirty injectors can cause it.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Possible dead battery
Hello. The battery light turning on when the engine is running indicates that system voltage is low. Everything required to run the engine, and everything in the car, will drain the battery. Most likely, it is the alternator, but the...
Check engine, VSC, and the red triangle and another light is on
While the car may be safe to drive, I would not recommend driving it with these codes on as many of these can cause a chain reaction of issues when one component is failing. I suggest having a local expert,...
My car is leaking transmission fluid - I can't diagnose the leak
Based on the NHTSA database (http://www.nhtsa.gov/) covering consumer complaints, as well as government mandated recalls and factory service bulletins, for your specific year, make and model, I do not see evidence of widespread complaints about transmission fluid leaks. Such leaks...
Replaced power steering pump and still have a hard steering.
Hi there. There is a PML valve that is on the rack and pinion steering on your vehicle. Check to see if the valve is working. The PML valve is is the speed sensitive steering valve for the steering system....
Will not shift past first gear at about 20 mph. What is causing this? 2002 Isuzu Rodeo Sport V6 3.2l
Hello - the lack of an upshift (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/car-won-t-shift-into-second-and-has-transmission-fluid-leaking-transmission-is-a-200r4-by-genesis-p) from 1st to 2nd could be dirty, burned fluid or clogged filter, or a failed Shift Solenoid "A". Low fluid level and low electrical system voltage can also make the transmission misbehave...
Is Mototehnika a good driveshaft brand?
Hi there. Mototehnika driveshafts are a descent design to have for your vehicle. The best driveshaft to install in the vehicle is an OEM specified driveshaft. There are lots of good reviews about the Mototehnika driveshaft design and a lot...
99 GMC SUBURBAN running lean and starving for fuel when stompped on.
Hi there. Is there a check engine light on? If so, what are the codes, freeze frame data? Stored codes and data will aid in diagnosing what is occurring. What does the data look like from the O2 sensors? Which...
What would cause my 2008 Ford Escape to growl at 40 mph and what would it cost to repair.
Hello. From what you are saying it does sound like you have a bearing failure. When they fail they will make a growling beginning at higher speed. You will then get it at lower speeds the more you drive with...
Car shakes and engine light blinking
Hi Luis. Thanks for contacting us today. What you are describing sounds quite a bit like a loose or damaged vacuum line. However, it's quite possible that you've got an ignition system problem that is causing an engine misfire to...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Dodge Ram
While While Chrysler has decided to give Ram its very own division, it seems impossible not to think of the Ram 1500 as a Dodge. After all, you’ll still buy your 2012 Ram at a Dodge dealer, and it remains...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Have a Tiny Parking Space
In In many cities parking spaces come at a premium, so you only want to purchase one small space. This small space will end up dictating what vehicle you purchase, so we’ve rounded up some great candidates. Must-haves Arm yourself...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re a Caterer
If If you are in the catering business, you need a reliable vehicle that will provide you with what you need to transport your food, linens, and other supplies. Generally speaking, you're better off buying gently used, because you will...