Q: Replacing front brake pad and reasonable dealership cost

asked by on October 20, 2016

I was told by a local Lexus dealership that my front brake pad is 3mm left that I need to replace it for $280 with rotor resurface and all parts and labor are included. Are they telling the true that I need replacement at 3mm? If yes, is it a reasonable price as I see it cost way less on YourMechanic.com here...appreciate your feedback!

My car has 50000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Brake rotors are turning blue Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote
Brake safety Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote
Brake Pads Replacement $150.17 - $479.65 Get a Quote

Hi there. I understand your concern. I start suggesting brake pad replacement at 3mm. Most technicians have a brake pad thickness gauge that takes the guesswork out of determining when to suggest brake pads replacement; 1-3mm is red, 4-6mm is yellow, and 7-10mm is green. At 3mm thickness the brake pads ability to dissipate heat has been drastically reduced as well as braking performance and can result in the what is called "hot spots" in the rotor; these spots look like blue or black spots and cannot be resurfaced to repair. Once the spots are in the rotor, resurfacing should not be attempted. Rotor replacement increases the cost of the repair when this occurs. YourMechanic has several available technicians that can assist you with a brake inspection and brake pad replacement as necessary at your home or office.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I fold the rear seatbacks?
Both sides of the rear seatback can fold down, which allows you extra storage space, or an opening to the trunk. Folding the rear seatbacks is very simple: Make sure that the front seats are not reclined. If the front...
The inside of rear wheels have more wear than outside
Yes, the inside tire wear (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/why-do-tires-wear-unevenly) is most likely attributed to the negative camber setting that can be accelerated by excessive toe-in as the tires are competing to determine the track of the vehicle. If you do get the alignment...
Car been sitting in garage for over a year. Bad starter.
Hello. There are quite a few things that you should do. The extent to which you do them will depend on need as you prioritize it with the budget you have. After replacing the starter (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/starter-replacement), you will also want...
My car engine is knocking constantly - what does this mean?
Hello. If the engine is running fine but the knock is consistent it may be a few different things. It can be coming from the camshaft actuator or it can be a rod knock starting. I have also had a...
My car speedometer is blinking while driving kindly please advise me?
I will need additional information to be able to help you, such as the year make and model of your vehicle. The speedometer might be blinking because of a short. It's also possible that the vehicle does not have the...
I have an very bad oil leak.
The crankshaft seal (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/front-crankshaft-seal-replacement) is in the area you are referring to. The crankshaft seal lasts maybe 100,000 miles or so. There are other gaskets and seals in that area that would have to be examined as well. If you...
How do I turn on the digital speedometer in my Peugeot 208 '16 plate.
Hi there. You could go through the setup on the controls with your settings as you were before. This time, you will need to get to the speed selection and scroll down. This will get to where you need to...
Does the car have to be driving down the road for the computer to sense a Fuel line EVAP leak?
In order for the EVAP system to complete the drive test you need to be at a cruise steady speed with engine warm and no check engine light on. The actual speed is needed will be in overdrive above 45...
I have an evap system issue with a check engine light code P0456 for a "really small leak"
Hi there. Unless you have professional EVAP system leak detection equipment, there really isn't much more you can do to isolate or diagnose the source of your EVAP leak or warning light. The one thing we can suggest is to...

Related articles

How the Parking Brake Works
A parking brake (also known as an emergency brake) is part of the vehicle’s braking system. You will see a...
How Long Do Brake Shoes (Rear) Last?
Most Most of the older cars on the market have two different types of brake systems on the front and rear of them. Generally, the front brakes will be pads and rotors, while the back will be drums and shoes....
How to Test a Power Brake Booster
If your brakes start to feel spongy, the root cause may be the power brake booster. Test your power brake booster to see if it needs replacement.