Q: Replaced the 02 sensor on my E46 and cel came on again with p1189 code again

asked by on March 28, 2017

I have changed spark plugs, 02 sensors, fuel filter, coils, maf, and cam shaft sensors on the car. Most recently was 02 sensors , cel come on with p1189 code again. What else should I do?

My car has 141000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi there. The problem with BMW-specific OBD-II codes is that they are unbelievably vague, In this case, the P1189 code indicates a fuel control fault detected from Bank 2 sensor 1. This does not automatically mean the O2 sensor is at fault. In fact, the most common cause of this code is a vacuum leak. It is also common for the electrical harness that is attached to the upstream O2 sensor to wear out overtime, which can also trigger this same trouble code. As much as I’d like to recommend having one of our mobile mechanics come to your location to determine where the fault exists, it might be better for you to contact a BMW specialist. However, before you do, inspect the electrical harness to the O2 sensor and also check for a vacuum leak to see if this resolves your issue.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I adjust the brightness of the lighting on the instrument panel?
You may want to adjust the lighting on the instrument panel to make it less bright or to increase the brightness, depending on your personal preference. Locate the button for adjusting the brightness of the panel lighting, which is located...
What is the Radio Data System and how do I use it?
Your car is equipped with an advanced audio system capable of displaying a lot of different information, particularly if you are listening to Radio Data System (RDS) stations. RDS is a system that allows you to explore categories of music,...
Water leaking into passenger's seat
It is very possible that your sunroof could be leaking water into your vehicle as this is a common problem. I would recommend having your rubber insulation and weather stripping checked to see where the leak is coming from. You...
Wheel is hard to turn
The power steering pump (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/power-steering-pump-replacement) may not be working properly and not producing any pressure. The pump would need to be checked for proper pressures using a tester gauge set. If the pump is producing enough pressure then the steering...
Looking for a ohms / resistance chart for the water thermal sensor switch on a 1985 toyota celica.
Hi there. Get a digital ohm meter and check the resistance on the coolant temperature sensor (water thermal sensor). You are looking for readings that are more than 200 ohms in variance between a cold and a warm engine. If...
I accidently over filled my oil 1qt will I be alright
If you overfilled the oil the crankshaft could contact the oil in the pan and cause the oil to foam up and cause engine to suck in the aerated oil into the oil pump and this could cause bearings to...
Whats the cost of clutch plate of automatic transmission???
Hi there. It really depends on the model of Honda you have and what is actually damaged. Typically the clutch plate is a part of a rebuild kit, which can range from $100 to $400 for the parts; based on...
Non-ethanol fuel
Hi There, Your truck should run just fine with non-ethanol fuel and in fact may run a bit better with pure non-ethanol fuel. Many of today’s engines are equipped to run on E85 fuel which is a high ethanol content...
There is a recall on 2013-2016 Honda Accord for Charging System Problems. Take your car to the nearest Honda dealer ASAP. I had to
Hi Antwan. It appears your question got cut off about the recall on your Honda. If you could, please write back and describe your question so we can give you the best possible advice. Thanks.

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW X5
The The 2012 BMW X5 is an SUV that offers both utility and ease of driving. The steering is responsive with a good amount of horsepower. If you are looking for a sportier SUV that offers versatility, the BMW X5...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2011 BMW X6 ActiveHybrid
This This “Sports Activity Vehicle” – a moniker bestowed by its maker – is one of those few cars that toes the line between SUV, hatchback sedan, and a just plain quirky car. Regardless of its true identity, however, the...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re Shorter Than Average
Vertically Vertically challenged? Hate getting behind the wheel and having to crane your neck to see? There’s nothing wrong with you, but there is something wrong with your car. It might be time to trade it in and take advantage...