Q: Poor gas economy, rough idling

asked by on January 14, 2017

Hi, I'm getting 12mpg on my sonata, recently changed exhaust manifold and catalytic converter with both 02 sensors changed, still didn't improve the fuel efficiency. I don't have a check engine light on, however, I have it once and I retrieved code p0456 which is a small leak somewhere. I reset it and didn't come back on for now. My car idles rough and sometimes doesn't start at the first try. Any ideas what would be the reason? I also had the air filter replaced, mass air flow cleaned and spark plugs replaced.

My car has 126000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Camshaft Position Sensor Replacement $119.59 - $907.58 Get a Quote

Hi There, There are a number of things that can cause poor fuel mileage. A faulty camshaft position sensor is one of them. The camshaft position sensor is a magnetic sensor that monitors camshaft speed to regulate ignition timing and fuel injection timing. It gathers and sends information about the car’s camshaft speed (and as a result the position of each piston) to the car’s electronic control module. This information is received by the computer, which then uses this data to further calculate the time of ignition and the timing of fuel injection required by the engine. When this is not working properly, you may experience a drop in power, poor idling, poor fuel mileage and problems starting the vehicle.

A clogged or dirty EGR valve may also cause poor fuel mileage. The EGR valve is a small component designed to allow the flow of exhaust gases into the intake manifold in controlled amounts. As such, it’s a simple valve that closes and opens as needed. The EGR valve has one single job to do, regardless of the system configuration, type of control and number of sensors: that is, to either open and direct exhaust gases into the combustion chamber, or to close and keep them from entering. Whenever you start the engine, the valve comes alive and waits in a closed position, blocking the flow of exhaust gases. Once the engine reaches operating temperature and speed increases, the valve, either through vacuum or electronic control will gradually open, allowing burned exhaust gases to enter and combine with the air-fuel mixture inside the combustion chamber. When the EGR valve is clogged or dirty, as they are prone to, it may not function properly causing the engine idle rough, stall at idle speeds, cause the car to get poor fuel mileage, or emit a strong smell of fuel due to excess hydrocarbons which also results in failing emissions tests.

A clogged or failing catalytic converter can also cause the vehicle to have poor fuel economy. As you may already know, the catalytic converter converts toxic exhaust gases into less harmful pollutants that are suitable to be expelled into the atmosphere. When this is clogged, this causes these gases to be backed up into the exhaust system not allowing the engine to breathe properly (think of a backed up sink). When this happens, the engine is forced to work much harder to expel these gases. This often results in the engine bogging down, hesitating, shaking and causing very poor fuel economy. I would recommend having a professional from YourMechanic come to your location to diagnose and inspect your vehicle.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do you turn the VSA on and off?
Your car’s vehicle stability assist (VSA) system is designed to provide better traction and handling during certain types of driving conditions. However, there may be times when you need to turn it off. For instance, you might need more power...
Random misfire while accelerating on "Drive"
Well it does sound like you have been trying to tackle quite the misfire and driving issues on your Honda Accord. Taking such measures as cleaning your Honda's throttle body, the EGR and the intake manifold are great steps toward...
Check engine light is on after replacing battery
Manually resetting the Check Engine Light on modern vehicles requires a diagnostic scan tool. Any automotive professional can do this for you. However, battery replacement should not have caused your Check Engine Light to come on. There may be an...
My car leaks oil and makes a loud sound when I drive.
Without more information and a vehicle inspection, it will not be possible to determine the exact cause of your concerns. A certified technician, like one from YourMechanic, will be able to pinpoint the source of the leak (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/oil-fluid-leak-inspection) and sound...
My car has an oil leak and a gas smell, could this be an emissions issue?
The oil leak may or may not be relevant. But if you are smelling gas in the exhaust, something is probably making that side too rich. It could be a misfire, but you would have misfire codes for that. It...
Making a ticking noise as I drive and in park at idle
Without hearing the noise, it's impossible to say what it is, But I'm going to suggest that you may have a valve noise because that is a sound that most people describe as "ticking" It's is a regular sound that...
Transmission or axle problem?
Hi there. Unfortunately, that sound you heard was most likely an internal component that has failed/broken. That doesn't mean that an axle failure couldn't be the source, either. This definitely needs to have an inspection to determine what has failed...
My radiator boils after the car has stopped. The cap has been replaced, thermostat, fan sensor, etc. 2006 Chrysler PT Cruiser
Hi there - the "boiling after shutoff (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-diagnose-a-cooling-system-problem-by-tyler-kirkland)" symptom is evidence of excess engine heat which is not being radiated by the radiator. Most likely, the "sealant" you added to the cooling system prior, is biting you back. The leak...
Car won't shift into park
It is possible that your shift lock solenoid has failed in the lock position. This solenoid is what allows the shifter to be moved only when the brakes are applied. When the brake pedal is depressed and the lock solenoid...

Related articles

How Are Car Sensors Protected From Heat and Debris?
Reliable car performance depends on sensors to collect and relay data. Some car sensors can be cleaned to make them work reliably again.
How Do Sensors Get Dirty or Damaged?
Car sensors measure and relay vital information to the ECU. Some sensors can get dirty from normal use, or fail if the car overheats or has a problem.
How Long Does an Evaporator Temperature Sensor (Switch) Last?
If If you have air conditioning in your vehicle, which pretty much all modern vehicles have, then you have an evaporator temperature sensor (switch). This switch plays an important role in making sure the correct temperature is attained, and that...