Q: My breaks sometimes stop car completely and sometimes it doesn't what would cause this?

asked by on September 05, 2016

When driving my breaks sometimes work great other times when I push my break peddle down the car slowly breaks but not completely where it takes longer for the car to break compleatly. The system has been bled and new calipers and break pads. I'm thinking the master cylinder but I see no leaks and have fluid in reservoir.. what's the issue?
My car has an automatic transmission.

Usually a person describes such an experience as more force than usual is needed to stop the car. I am not exactly sure what you are experiencing here, so I will address a few things. Speed and weight of your vehicle will make braking less effective. All things being equal, if you are coming to a stop at the exact same speed and the exact same distance, your master cylinder could certainly be the issue. So could your anti-lock brake system. Your master cylinder can have internal leaks that will affect its ability to create enough pressure at your wheels. Your anti-lock breaks have the ability to do the same thing, but in much different ways.

It sounds as if someone has done a lot of work to your car already without experiencing your issue. This suggests you have an intermittent problem. Intermittent problems are inherently difficult to catch. In order to catch your problem, you will need to leave your car with someone for several days so they car do the best they can to recreate the problem. If stopping is still safe, I would recommend waiting until the problem becomes worse and is much easier to identify.

Usually if it is a anti-lock brake problem, there will be a anti-lock brake light on or the brake pedal will bounce when braking.

I recommend having a certified technician, like one from YourMechanic, diagnose your brake system firsthand to help you figure this out.

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car idling and running rough
Hello, the engine is equipped with an electronic valve called an idle air control valve. The idle air control valve lets a metered amount of air into the engine at idle to have a comfortable idle and ensure the engine...
fan runs at high speed when car it turned on.
Hello there, you have a few different faults with your 2000 Mercedes. Your car's fans have two speeds, low and high. The High speed setting should only be on during heavy load and high temperatures. The fans should shut off...
Car is not starting but the lights are on
There are several possibilities here - the neutral safety switch may have failed (requires you to be in Park/Neutral to start), the ignition switch may have failed (bad contacts), or the starter itself (solenoid or motor) may have failed. I...
Car cranking without key in ignition
This is usually a sign of a faulty starter solenoid. There are a few wires that connect to the starter solenoid coming from the battery, the starter, and the ignition switch. When these wires are connected incorrectly or when there...
Remote car starter and automatic door locking mechanism won't work after crash.
Hi there. With having the battery cable loose, that caused the computer to reset and lose its memory. I recommend reprogramming the key fob to the vehicle to allow the door locks and ignition to work. First put the key...
How long does it take to replace an EGR tube on my 2004 Navigator?
In order to replace the EGR tube it can be replaced in less than an hour. The tube may not be the only issue though and the intake manifold EGR ports may be clogged and need the intake manifold to...
Tilt wheel problems.
You cannot alter the steering column to tilt up more. You would have to replace the column with one that has the tilt function.
I took my 04 GMC Envoy to better brakes for less as I needed to have it pass smog and the check engine light was on. They said I n
Inasmuch as YourMechanic is mobile, you need not bring the car anywhere as the certified mechanic will come to you and take care of the radiator replacement. If you desire mobile replacement, please simply use YourMechanic's radiator replacement service page...
How do I replace spark plugs on a 1991 Plymouth Acclaim
Hi there. If you have not completed this type of job before, I would recommend one of two things. First, purchase a service and repair manual for your 1991 Plymouth Acclaim online; as it will have detailed instructions and what...

Related articles

How Often Should Brakes Be Replaced?
Brake pads and brake rotors wear out over time. How long brakes last depends on the brake material, as well as your driving patterns.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Brake Caliper
Common signs include brake fluid leaks, abnormal sounds, and vehicle pulling to the left or right.
The Top 10 Most Problematic Cars
All cars have issues, from grinding brakes to gasket leaks. The Ford Explorer's and Honda Civic's bad transmissions rank them as the most problematic.