Q: Is it bad to over-fill engine oil?

asked by on April 11, 2016

Is an over-filled engine oil bad? I've had my Mazda taken to the dealership for fluid replacement and each time I noticed that the oil level was above the second mark.

Yes it is bad. Engines are made for a certain amount of oil. If you put too much oil, it takes up space that wasn’t taken up before and can cause compression problems that can blow seals out.

You’d want to empty it out so that it’s just at the full level and go someplace else to get your oil changed, because will need to be at the full level. That’s what a pro does. I always look them up. I don’t even trust a gas sign. I look at my computer and if it says 3.4 quarts, I put 3.4 quarts. You want to be a pro when you’re changing it and not put the wrong amount in because it can ruin it.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

my car swayss back and forth on its own. starting at 30mph
Hello. If you have replaced these parts and it is still swaying then you need to check the tires (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-tell-the-difference-in-size-for-a-car-tire-by-jason-unrau). Make sure that they are the correct size. Aftermarket wheels will also cause this problem if they are not the...
grinding or scraping sound coming from the front L wheel.
This sounds like the brake pads or bearings are bad; they could be binding the wheel in the left side. You should have the noise issue inspected (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-is-making-a-noise-inspection) and any needed repairs done. A jerking issue could lead to total...
Transmission replacement cost
A complete, re-manufactured transmission for your car would cost about $2,000 plus the labor cost to install it. Inasmuch as your car has only 130,000 miles, if you are having transmission problems, it might be possible to repair your existing...
The car is not accelerating right and the speedometer is jumping.
Hello. The speed info goes from the VSS (vehicle speed sensor (transmission output sensor)) mounted on the tranny, to the PCM (powertrain control module (computer)) mounted on the passenger firewall, to the dash speedometer. If the speedometer is not functioning...
Poor acceleration and car jerking when going going on a mild/steep slope or carrying more people
Hi there, thanks for writing in. It sounds like you might be experiencing a problem with your clutch as opposed to the engine. Typically, around 130,000 miles, the clutch of a manual transmission will begin to develop problems engaging fully....
My check engine light came on after getting a jump start from AAA and when i got home i turned the car off and the light stays on
Hello. From what you describe it would appear that your vehicle is experiencing more than one issue. P2070 is the code indicating the intake manifold tuning valve is stuck open. This may be linked to your performance issue. Dark smoke...
The air conditioner and heater control panel has no power, no lights, nothing
Since you seem to get some temporary action by messing with the fuses, the problem may lie in the power distribution box. Underneath the fuse panel is a network of connections, some of which may overheat in an older car....
How much for a tune up
Annual "tune-ups" are not really applicable to modern vehicles. Instead, what is typically of importance is following the vehicle manufacturer's "maintenance schedule". The required maintenance at this time for your car will depend on the vehicle history. In particular, if...

Related articles

How Does a Car's Air Conditioning Work?
All All across North America, a climate change occurs every year. The cooler spring temperatures give way to warmer weather. In some areas this lasts for two months, and in others it lasts six months or longer. It’s called summer....
How Long Does an Axle Shaft Seal Last?
The The axle shaft seal in your car is a gasket that keeps fluid from leaking out of the vehicle’s differential. The differential itself is what sends power from the engine of your car to its transmission, and finally to...
How to Replace a Wheel Seal
Wheel seals are part of the wheel bearing system and keep dirt and debris away from these bearings. Replace wheel seals if grease leaks from bearings.