Q: I'm being told my rear dif is toast. How does this happen? Is it due to lack of rear dif oil changes or do they just wear out? 2009 VW Tiguan

asked by on January 31, 2017

Our Tiguan was making an embarrassingly loud noise when driven. It felt like we were dragging heavy metal. We were told our rear differential is gone. We were also told it's an expensive job to replace. Our questions are: 1) what should we expect to pay (Canadian dollars)? 2) we were told this is a rare mechanical failure- so why did ours go? We have been getting it serviced by the dealer as they suggested. Is it possible they missed replacing the rear dif oil? Should I be checking for that as I've read the oil needs replacing every 12000-50000km. 3) is it better to fix or get a new car?

My car has 122000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hello - your Tiguan is equipped with a Haldex torque-sensing system which directs power thru the differential to the axle (left/right) which has the best traction. Think of the differential as the reduction gears and axle(s) drive, and the Haldex as the mechanism which decides which axle drive to send power through. This is important because the Haldex, and the differential have different lubrication types, and a different lube maintenance schedule. If the differential was being serviced, but not the Haldex, this could be an issue. Which component failed - the Haldex, or the differential itself? The differential proper should be good for many more miles of service unless it was abused. The Haldex is more sensitive to maintenance. I recommend a discussion with the service center regarding your service history, and which component is actually now broken.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Tips for maintaining my Honda after 100,000 miles?
The best recommendation I can give to any car owner is follow the manufacturer's maintenance schedule. The 100,000-mile service typically includes inspecting and, if necessary, replacing the fluids in your transmission, hydraulic brake system, and cooling system. Engine and cabin...
Car accelerates, hesitates, and then runs normally.
I would have a technician diagnose the acceleration problem (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/engine-hesitates-during-acceleration-inspection). This problem could be caused from either the engine or transmission. They will need to pull codes on the car in order to determine the cause.
Car running fast after warmup.
Having your car run fast like this sounds like a frustrating experience. Let us get you pointed in the right direction so you can drive your car worry-free. The symptom you are experiencing with your vehicle sounds like something called...
Car running rough with little power
The crankshaft sensor is needed by the computer to see the engine RPM's. The engine will run bad or not at all if the sensor is failing or has failed. I recommend seeking a certified mechanic to come and test...
Transmission slipping
Hello...if it is a shift solenoid (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/downshift-solenoid-replacement), that electronically controlled valve is in the transmission "valve body". Often, the part can be replaced without removing the transmission. However, the valve body might have to be removed. This is a fairly...
Engine stalls when accelerating from idle
Hi there - excellent work, I commend you on your diagnostic skills! Yes, based on your description and testing, I would agree that the fuel pressure regulator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-fuel-pressure-regulator) is the most likely candidate for this problem. Bear in mind that...
1995 f150 Possible blown head gasket
It sounds like you may in fact have a blown head gasket. A blown head gasket may cause a number of different symptoms. A head gasket that fails between cylinders will generally cause a misfire and potentially compression leaks from...
My truck feels like it won't go in drive while I'm driving
You should have the computer and transmission scanned to see if the system is storing codes that can be fixed without an internal transmission issue. The codes will need to have the pinpoint tests done to isolate the problem.
95 toyota camry starts but doesn't drive or goes into reverse? 200k. 1st it was reverse only reversed when cold after a drive or
First you will need to verify the fluid is full and then retest it. If it still does not move then you may have bad internal transmission clutches and clutch bands and would require overhaul or replacement transmission.

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Rock Climber
If If you’re a rock climber, you want a vehicle that gets you where you need to go, even if the terrain gets rough. You may be living out of your vehicle at times, so you also want a rig...
How to Buy Good Quality Differential/Gear Oil
Gear, Gear, or differential, oil is used to lubricate the gears in a car’s transmission so that it can shift smoothly and easily. This type of fluid is generally used on standard transmissions, whereas transmission fluid is used in automatic...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Support Bearing
Common signs include unusual noises and shuddering during acceleration.