Q: High idle in the morning and after sitting for 5+ hours

asked by on October 06, 2016

When I start my truck in the morning, normal warm temperatures, the RPMs shoot up to 2500 and drops down to 1500-1800 and just fluctuates for about 10 seconds. Then the truck shakes a bit.

I went to a dealership that diagnosed no issues. No lights on or anything. They basically said they found large amount of carbon build up in the throttle body (which at 45k, I'm not sure if that's accurate). So they cleaned the throttle body and fuel system. Also they performed idle relearn and fuel composition relearn.

I've had my truck back about a week and it started fluctuating again. It was good for about a week.

So I'm skeptical to take it to another Chevy dealer or shop cause this shop couldn't find the issue. They just did something they thought would fix the issue.

Please help as I don't have much cash and I've wasted $200 on that useless trip to the dealership already.

Thanks!

My car has 45000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Engine idle speed is high Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hi, thanks for writing in. I’d like to start by saying, you haven’t wasted your money. Even if your issue hasn’t been repaired, they did some quality maintenance that will help your truck last many more miles. I understand your frustration with this though. You went there for an issue that wasn’t taken car of.

I want to offer you another perspective about this. This may be a change to what you are used to with your truck, but the reality is it really isn’t a problem that does anything but create a higher idle than you are used to. I am certain something has changed, but determining what small change has occurred in a complicated system will most often take a lot of time to figure out. More time equals more money. More money for an issue that doesn’t seem to create a problem. So you need to decide, is it worth the money to figure out why this change has occurred?

As a technician, with my own car, I can tell when something has changed, but often it is too early to determine exactly what it was. I will often wait until the symptom becomes pronounced enough to easily figure out. I have that issue with my front end at this moment. It began to wonder slightly more on the highway. But chasing the problem now will likely lead to an inconclusive diagnosis. I will wait a bit longer until the play becomes more pronounced and I will know for sure. I would suggest that this method may be the most cost effective and least frustrating path. The alternative is hoping you have found a technician that has experienced your issue and has successfully found the source. Otherwise, you are likely to have the same experience.

If I were tasked to work on your car regardless, I would first smoke machine your motor looking for cold vacuum leaks while I had a scanner connected and monitoring all scan data. Even so, this may or may not reveal the source of the change.

If you would like a technician from YourMechanic take a crack at this, I recommend the following inspection: Engine idle speed is high inspection

Be sure to send the technician a note explaining this is a start up only condition.

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Electrical problems?
Hello, thanks for writing in about your Jeep Patriot. The low voltage condition from the alternator not charging will cause the Totally Integrated Control Module (TIPM) to not work correctly. You should have the battery charged up completely and then...
Difficult to turn my steering wheel to the left, but not right
Hi there, The description you have given of the steering being hard to turn in one direction, leads me to believe, the rack and pinion is at fault. The power steering pump failure, would make it difficult to turn in...
My car ran out of gas and now it won't start - 2001 Infiniti QX4
When you ran the fuel pump dry of fuel, the fuel pump may have seized up. Fuel pumps use the fuel in the tank to keep it cool so it does not overheat and also lubricates the internal parts as...
Can I drive with just one lug nut loose on one tire? The nut is stripped so I cannot take it off. But 3 out of 4 nuts are on tight
Hi there. I've seen many vehicles on the road with a lug nut missing and it does seem to work. However, what these people are unaware of is that improper/uneven wheel nut torque is a major cause of brake vibrations....
My cars makes a rhythmic tapping noise while idling and the noises accelerates and loud end when my rpms go up,
Without listening to the noise myself and going on what you describe then I would have to say it is an engine piston rod knocking inside the motor. You should have a mechanic like one from YourMechanic listen to the...
When driving all the time I hear a fluttering sound. Seems to be coming from my right front area and gets worst the faster I drive.
The noise that your are hearing could be the lug nuts being loose or the wheel bearing hub assembly could be failing. Check the lug nuts and tighten them if they are loose. If the lug nuts are tight, then...
Just had my transmission oil leak fixed and now my car is acting up, when I'm slowing down it starts to like stall n then it stops
Hi there. Typically a slipping transmission will not cause the engine to vibrate and shake while the vehicle is in gear and nearly stalling when you stop. This is typically caused by a fuel system component failure, such as a...
High idling 3000-4000 rpm after cleaning throttle body...even after warming .....relearn procedure not working nissan altima 2007
Hi Muhibur. Thanks for sending your question today. This could be either a vacuum leak or an issue with the ECU that is causing this high RPM issue. The only way to know for sure is to have a professional...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2011 Cadillac DTS
The The 2011 Cadillac DTS is a full-size sedan that offers the comfort and luxury you expect from this automaker. It manages to combine a comfortable ride with tremendous amounts of cargo capacity in the trunk, although it isn’t without...
2012 Chevrolet Silverado vs. 2012 Dodge Ram: Which One Should I Buy?
When you are looking for a way to get a load of mulch or gravel, or need to haul a large trailer or boat behind your vehicle, chances are you are looking for a truck. Trucks are not meant to...
2012 Subaru Outback vs. 2012 Chevrolet Impala: Which One Should I Buy?
When you compare a 4-door sedan versus a 4-door wagon, there are going to be some obvious differences. Even though the Outback looks car-like, the ride, the handling, and the mileage are going to make it more similar to an...