Q: Hi Jeffrey. I am about to buy a new car and I stand for between a Subaru BRZ/Scion FRS and a Mini Cooper S, both used, 2013-2014 w

asked by on January 27, 2017

Hi Jeffrey. I am about to buy a new car and I stand for between a Subaru BRZ/Scion FRS and a Mini Cooper S, both used, 2013-2014 with around 40k miles. Which one is the most reliable on mechanics and which is less costly to maintain and repair? (I assume Subaru has a great reputation). Thank you.

I would suggest checking the Kelly Blue Book website with specifics related to your zip code as market prices of cars vary by zip code. This will give you a baseline for determining whether or not the car is within a general range of the asking price. Secondly, as you know, with any car the life expectancy of it depends largely on the maintenance schedule the owner has maintained, the driving conditions it is subjected to, the driving habits of the owner and many other factors. Often times when a car has had internal damage or even slight cosmetic damage, it may be difficult to tell without looking closely or performing an in depth inspection. As with any vehicle, proper maintenance schedules are a key factor to prolonging the longevity of the vehicle and avoiding unnecessary costly repair bills due to neglecting proper maintenance intervals. I would suggest having an expert from Your Mechanic come to your location to perform a thorough pre-purchase inspection prior to making your purchase.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car rumbles when accelerating for the first time after not using the car for 12 or more hours.
Hi there: What you're describing could be several issues ranging from clogged fuel injectors (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-injector-replacement) or dirty fuel filter (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-filter-replacement) to electronics related with a problem with the ignition coil or a sensor; even a vacuum leak. If you turn...
cooled is full in my car but radiator not take cooled for cold..as a result tempreature is so high after 15 km..run
If I understand you correctly, your radiator stays cool and the engine overheats. If the engine thermostat is stuck closed, it will restrict coolant flow to the radiator and the engine will overheat. Have a mechanic inspect the overheating condition...
Crank no start
Hey there, thanks for writing in about your 2003 Ford Explorer. It sounds to me like you either have no fuel or bad fuel at the injectors, or no spark to spark plugs. Try to narrow the problem to one...
fuses blow, check engine light on, compressor needs replacing
As far as the power window fuse, there is obviously a shorted circuit causing the fuse to pop every time. The components of the system must be inspected by an automotive electrical technician to track down the fault. The stalling...
Check engine light comes on intermittently
If the Check Engine Light is coming on then it would have set a code. The code may have been read, but a problem is not found or the mechanic could not find the problem. I would need to know...
Car over heats even though I have coolant in the engine
The most common cause is the cooling fan is not coming on or there is a restriction in the airflow across the radiator. You should have this checked first then see if the radiator is flowing coolant through all the...
transmission wont push back on clutch slave cylinder
Hello, The slave cylinder is meant to be bench bled just as a master cylinder is. If this is not done it can cause air to remain in the slave cylinder. This will allow the slave cylinder to fully compress...
When turning the key to start the car sometimes the engine turns over and starts sometimes it doesn't .
Be sure you have a fully charged battery that passes a load test (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-is-dead-inspection). Starters motors can display intermittent operation if they are faulty. With a fully charged battery, if the starter motor does not run that signifies an electrical...
i was driving my acura integra , i had stopped at a red light i out it in 1st gear but wasn´t going nowhere like if my e brake was
Hello, thank you for writing in. The lack of transmission fluid is why you are not able to send the power from the engine to the wheels. The first step is to identify and fix the cause of the transmission...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Smoke
No No lectures here – you know that smoking is bad for you. In fact, right now, only about 15% of adults in the United States smoke, and that means that over the years, motor vehicle manufacturers have become less...
How to Register a Car in New Hampshire
One One of the best places to move to is New Hampshire due to its natural beauty and the great residents that inhabit this state. If you are making a move to New Hampshire, you will have to make sure...
What is the Engine Variable Valve Timing (VVT) Oil Control Valve all about?
A A VVT solenoid is responsible for maintaining fuel economy by regulating the supply of oil to the VVT hub. Keep in mind: Low oil levels can also cause problems with the VVT solenoid and other timing system parts. Each...