Q: Engine makes weird noise

asked by on July 31, 2016

I start my 02 Bonneville and the engine makes weird knocking noise and gets a little louder under acceleration somtimes the car wont even start at all but when it does it makes the that noise agian i could probably take it on a quick 5 minute drive before the engine cuts off and the car wont start up till its been sitting there for a couple of hours i also have a vid if need to i can show it please help me with this issue thanks.

My car has 197590 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The knocking noise and the dying are most likely two different problems. Diagnosing sounds is inherently not possible without being present. Even with a video. There are some very specific noises a car can make that with experience a technician learns what they are. In your case, remember I haven’t heard the noise, a knock on start up and on acceleration is usually a crank shaft issue. The crank shaft has two sets of bearings. The main bearings and the rod bearings and both make distinctly different sounds. Only experience has taught me their differences. I could not have heard the difference if someone had tried to explain them to me in a classroom or in a conversation. Either way, it will at the very least require the oil pan to be removed and the cranks bearing to be inspected.

But don’t jump to this conclusion without an experienced technician has listened to your noise. As for your dying while driving, the 3.8l has an ignition module that commonly displays this problem. As the motor warms up, the internals of the module expand and the motor uses spark. When diagnosing the GM 3.8l, I look for spark and injector pulse. If it has injector pulse an no spark, I suspect the ignition module. If it is missing spark and injector pulse, I suspect the crank sensor.

If I suspect the cranks sensor, I connect a scan tool and observe the crank sensor data and waveform. From this I will know if the crank sensor is the issue or if further diagnostic time is necessary.

Keep in mind, these are the pattern failures I have seen on the GM 3.8l motor. I recommend you book an appointment with a certified technician, such as one from YourMechanic, to diagnose your starting issue and the noise you’re hearing firsthand.

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

2004 Chevy Express makes noise while idling
The first thing you'd want to check is the power steering (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-power-steering-pump). A lot of times, they groan on those. If it's not the power steering, a lot of times it would be the transmission. If it's coming from the...
radio not working
The blower motor only working on high speed is a common symptom of a failing blower motor resistor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/cooling-fan-resistor-replacement); but the fact the radio stopped working at the same time is unusual. It's possible that this could still be two...
Brake light circuit warning light illuminated - 1998 BMW 323is
Sometimes, there is just enough corrosion on the end of the bulb to trigger this warning despite the bulbs illuminating correctly. Using some emory cloth or very fine sandpaper, rub the contact end of each of the brake bulbs to...
Steering wheel stiff when parking
Hey there. The two main components for your power steering system are the steering pump and the rack & pinion steering unit. If the power steering pump was run low on fluid for a period of time, it may have...
Rear passenger side wheel completely locked up.
It is possible that the parking brake cable has seized, due to rust, at that wheel position. That would be relatively easy to determine based on a visual inspection. If you desire that this problem be diagnosed by a certified...
Car won't turn over or start but will push start.
Hi there. It could be your distributor or another ignition system component such as a crankshaft or cam position sensor, faulty spark plugs or a bad coil. It's also possible that your ignition relay is damaged, if you're able to...
How to seal an oil leak on a chevy 350?
This hole is specifically designed to be in that location and is for the oil pan dipstick. This is used to check the oil. I would suggest going to your local parts store and purchasing the correct dipstick for your...
Car won't stay in park and I have to use a lot of force to try to get it to turn on.
Hi there. Land rovers are notorious for having this problem after 10 years or so. In most cases, it's a problem with the actual shifter, with the shift gate being either damaged or clogged with excessive debris. To determine the...
How long should it take to replace an AC compressor and condenser in my Saturn Astra?
Hi there. If you'd like to receive an estimate, which would include the estimated labor hours along with replacement parts and supplies, you can click this link (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/ac-condenser-replacement). Generally speaking, the job itself takes about 3 to 5 hours to...

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing PCV Valve Hose
Common signs include poor fuel economy, the Check Engine Light coming on, engine misfires while idling, and noise from the engine.
How to Find Top Dead Center
There There are many reasons why you might need to find an engine’s top dead center. Top dead center is the point when the piston of the number one cylinder in an engine is at its highest point, and on...
How to Replace a Yaw Rate Sensor
Yaw rate sensors monitor traction, stability, and the anti-lock braking system to alert you when the car tilts at an unsafe degree.