Q: Can 2 serpentine belts need replacing within 11 years and can the alternator suddenly fail without warning ?

asked by on September 23, 2016

The original serpentine belt was replaced in 2008 as part of my 75K mile tune up. Yesterday, my battery warning light came on and a message appeared in my DIC that said battery not charging. I replaced the battery and the warning messages went off. While driving it today they came back on. I took it back to the dealership. My battery now has 65% life left in it. They started the diagnoses of my engine. Apparently, my serpentine belt is "bad" and my alternator is failing. However, it drives perfectly fine. There is no dimming of lights, no engine stalling or odd noises. Is it possible for an alternator to fail without any warning? (It is the original one that came with my suv.) Is it normal to replace two serpentine belts in 11 years with less than 130k miles on my suv? Could it be anything else that they are overlooking? I would really appreciate any suggestions you could recommend. Thanks!

My car has 129683 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Drive Belt Tensioner Replacement $149.81 - $643.33 Get a Quote
Alternator Replacement $166.62 - $1297.14 Get a Quote

Hello. There is a huge variance in manufacturer estimates of serpentine belt lifetime. This is understandable because operating conditions vary, vehicle designs vary and the belt material will degrade at different rates. You should get at least 50,000 miles out of the belt. If less than 50,000 miles there is a problem which itself could vary in cause (lousy belt quality, vehicle design issue, defective pulley bearings and so forth). In your circumstance, you want to make sure that all of the ball bearing mounted pulleys that the belt rides on are in good condition.

These bearings sometimes wear out and the grease can dry out, creating friction and unwanted noise. Also, the belt tensioner should be inspected. Basically, any and everything that the belt runs on should be inspected for smooth operation. Alternators are diagnosed by measuring their voltage output, both loaded and unloaded. As long as the alternator’s output (voltage) is within specification, and it holds up under load (with all car accessories on) it is usable. The thing to do is ask exactly what the output of the alternator was during their diagnostic. Some shops should even be able to print out these test results (the voltage output) or at least demonstrate the results for you by showing you the test instrument in action. Should you desire a second opinion to be sure you are getting good advice, YourMechanic, in your local area, will be pleased to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Subaru making high-pitched sound when starting.
I would take it to the dealer and have them diagnose it some more there are some common whining noises coming from that car. It could be in the transmission, the wheel bearing, drive shaft, fuel pump or something else....
Sunroof not closing all the way
Hi. Sometimes debris lands inside the track and can cause similar complications. If thats not the case, a certified mechanic from YourMechanic can inspect the sunroof system. It can be a switch problem or the sunroof module just needs to...
Having problems with my air conditioner putting out different temperatures from different vents
Hello. Typically when you experience only one side of the system doing this, it is because of a bad air door actuator motor. These are common failures on most cars. If I knew what kind of vehicle this was, I...
Chirping noise when the car hits a bump
Hi. The chirping sound you are experiencing on your 2010 Nissan Cube sounds like it could be from noisy strut springs (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/suspension-springs-replacement) or a worn drive belt (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/serpentine-drive-belt-replacement). Check the condition of the strut springs and drive belt to try...
Car is idling rough and missing
This may be a sign of a faulty MAP sensor. The Manifold Absolute Pressure (MAP) sensor senses engine load and generates a signal that is proportional to the amount of vacuum in the intake manifold. The engine computer then uses...
Can a poorly installed wheel bearing cause extensive damage when driven on?
Hi there: It's highly unlikely that the installation of a wheel bearing causes mechanical damage that the mechanic has listed above. Typically those components (Axle shaft leaking, steering knuckle, lower ball joint, lower control arm, front strut) are not touched...
engine light comes on after oil change service
Hi there: On modern vehicles, there are two different types of "warning lights"; routine service lights and trouble code warning lights. In most cases, when you have a routine service light that illuminates, it's set to do so at certain...
where is the crankshaft sensor on an LDV Maxus 2008
Hi there: Unfortunately, we don't service commercial vehicles like the LDV Service van you're referring to in this inquiry. You might want to contact LDV service department (http://www.ldvusa.com/service-and-support/service-tips/) to receive a schematic for your vehicle.
1. Vehicle is making a loud groaning sound when turning during very cold weather. 2. Will only allow fuel filling in short spurts.
Hi There, The groaning noise you are referring to may possibly be a failing wheel bearing. A wheel bearing (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services1/wheel-bearings-replacement) will usually fail due to pitting or small damage on the surface of the rollers or the bearing race. Both...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 GMC Acadia
When When it comes to finding the right SUV for your family, it seems like there are always a lot of compromises to be made. One vehicle is so performance and off-road oriented that you can’t imagine taking your kids...
Is it Safe to Drive With the Battery Light On?
The battery of the vehicle supplies electric energy to your car. It powers the lights, ignition system, the radio, headlights, and much more....
How to Tighten a Drive Belt
If you have just replaced your drive belt (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/common-signs -your-drive-belt-needs-replacement) and you are noticing high-pitched squeaking or squealing under the hood,...