Q: 1995 BMW M3 won't pass smog at idle, random misfire, new coils, plugs, injectors, knock sensors, tested sensors with scan tool

asked by on July 01, 2017

I have a random sputter at idle, won't pass smog at idle 200/100HC, passes at 2500rpm. tested sensors with scan tool and all are working new gaskets and hoses new bosch ignition coils new injectors new knock sensors new o2 sensor(only 1 on car, pre cat) fuel pressure regulator fuel filter tested computer and dinan and Turner chip re timed engine 3 times along with smoke test 3 times swapped MAF and no change( 2 good ones off friends car) only things I haven't replaced are fuel pump(tested with fuel pressure gauge at 51 psi) before fuel pressure regulator throttle position sensor and vanos solenoid/vanos ICV(cleaned a couple months ago, I live on west coast and had another e36 have a very rough idle from ICV getting salt buildup) the problem is it is so slight and random most shops don't even know it's misfiring but it just won't pass smog Thanks for reading and if you have multiple options I will perform all today that are possible thank you!!

My car has 200000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Since you have replaced so many parts , it would be very difficult to determine what exactly is causing this without performing a physical inspection. I wouild stronly recommend having your vehicle inspected by a qualified professional to trace down what is causing this issue. Consider YourMechanic as vehicle inspections can be performed at your home or office.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How can I stop my engine rattling?
Let me start by saying that there could be one or more issues contributing to a loud rattle and vibration. Diagnosing a vibration and rattle are a hands-on skill to determine the correct repair. There are two areas that should...
How do I create a MyKey?
You can create a MyKey with just a few steps: 1. Press the Up/Down buttons on the steering wheel until Settings is displayed on the instrument panel, then press the OK button. 2. Press the Up/Down buttons until MyKey is...
What does the malfunction indicator Warning Light mean?
The malfunction indicator Warning Light is on your instrument cluster. It illuminates when the On-Board Diagnostics-Second Generation (OBD II) system detects an issue. The OBD II system monitors your vehicle’s emissions. When the malfunction indicator Warning Light is illuminated, it...
Suddenly turns off
Hello. The most common caused of this on your vehicle are the ignition switch (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-ignition-switch) and the main relay (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-main-relay-computer-fuel-system). Most of the time it is the main relay. This is also known as the PGMFI relay. This relay fails...
Starting issue, fuel smell
The fuel pressure would need to be checked to make sure the pressure regulator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-pressure-regulator-replacement) is not leaking fuel and that the pressure is correct. You may have a leaking injector (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-injector-replacement) if the pressure is okay. I recommend having...
Oil leaking engine won't hold oil but car starts
As you know, an oil leak can range from somewhat minor to very serious depending on the location of the leak and how quickly it is leaking. I would recommend not starting the car at all until getting this leak...
Car shut off when oil light came on, won't restart. What could it be?
Hello, What you are describing may be related to a safety switch that automatically causes the ECM to shut down the ignition to the engine when the oil pressure sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/oil-pressure-light-is-on-inspection) reaches a certain level. This is the computer's way...
Jumping dead car battery but alarms keeps beeping? 2002 Honda Accord
Hello - most modern cars "interpret" a battery swap as a possible theft attempt (i.e. hot wiring). To shut off the alarm each time a battery is replaced (or you jump it off from dead), shut the engine off in...
the engine has a melattic rattleing sound and oil leaking
Hello, thank you for writing in. The noise may be related to the oil leak. Low oil pressure and lack of lubrication to the engine causes a large number of engine components to wear quickly and rub when they should...

Related articles

5 Essential Things to Know About Luxury Vehicles
There’s There’s something to be said about the looks and offerings of luxury vehicles, but appearances can always be deceiving. If you’re considering buying a luxury car, there are a few things you need to know before you make your...
The Best Used Cars to Buy if You Live Close to the Ocean
If If you live close to the ocean, your vehicle is going to be far more vulnerable to rust than if you lived further inland. And the fact is, when it comes to resisting rust, not all vehicles are created...
5 Comfortable Sports Cars Your Parents Won't Complain About Riding In
The most comfortable sports cars combine high performance with a smooth ride. Options include the Alpina B6, Audi S8 Plus, and Mercedes-AMG S65.