Q: Catalytic converter replacement

asked by on October 18, 2016

I brought my car to a mechanic for a tune up. Everything was running good and no check engine light. Now all of a sudden I have to replace my catalytic converter and my check engine light is on. Did the mechanic mess up my car or is it a problem that I caused

My car has 170000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Catalytic Converter Replacement $288.41 - $1959.69 Get a Quote

Hello. It’s quite possible that there is no one at fault here. It may just be unfortunate timing. I’m assuming that you have had the codes read and that is why you have decided you need to replace the catalytic converter. If there were no codes present other that catalyst efficiency, then it might just be normal wear and tear.

If there were any misfire codes or other problems before the tune up, driving it in that condition may have lead to a catalyst failure, but 170,000 miles is not really a premature failure. Many cars need to have at least one catalyst replacement before they reach 200,000 miles. YourMechanic can send a technician to your home who can replace your catalyst and advise you further as to what other conditions may exist.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How Do I Keep the Fuel System Clean?
Ideally, you shouldn't have to do anything to your car to keep the fuel system clean (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-can-i-keep-my-fuel-system-clean). However, our cars don't live in an ideal world. Probably the most common effect of burning gasoline in our engines is the buildup...
SRS airbag light on
Hello! An airbag light will usually set due to a fault in the SRS circuit. Most of the time it will set due to a open squib in the SRS circuit. A squib is simply the factory term for air...
Car stalling after idling for a few minutes
Firstly, the engine should be checked for failure codes and then the throttle body should be cleaned for any carbon build up that may be on the throttle plates. The idle position should be relearned as well so that the...
Check engine light on, D blinks
The Check Engine Light is detecting a fault with a system. The D light is representing at fault with your transmission. You possibly damaged some wiring when you drove over the curb creating this fault. The transmission will default if...
P0135 O2 sensor heater circuit bank 1 sensor 1
Hello. P0135 (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0135-obd-ii-trouble-code-o2-sensor-heater-circuit-malfunction-bank-1-sensor-1-by-jay-safford) is the code for an oxygen sensor heater circuit malfunction, bank 1 sensor 1. If bank 1 sensor 1 oxygen sensor has been replaced, then it may be possible that the issue is with the wiring or...
Will the mass airflow sensor stop my car from reaching proper acceleration?
Hi, thanks for writing in. A faulty mass airflow sensor can certainly effect power, performance, and economy. If the engine computer does not read the mass airflow or any other sensor, it relies on basic settings to run. It does...
Screeching serpentine belt when the a/c is on. Is this a problem with the serpentine belt?
Hi there. There is a problem with the alternator or a/c compressor clutch pulley. Check the pulleys out on each item and see which one is creating a heavy load or a skipping feeling as if the bearing is seizing...
The battery light is showing on the dashboard
This may be a sign of a weak battery, a failing voltage regulator or failing alternator. As you may know, the alternator is responsible for charging the battery while the engine runs by generating amperage and recharging the battery while...
Check engine light on and the engine is idling really bad.
The check engine light code P0496 (https://www.obd-codes.com/p0496) leads to the evaporative charcoal canister purge valve solenoid may not be functioning properly. Check the purge valve solenoid (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/canister-purge-solenoid-replacement) on the charcoal canister and see if there is a smell of gas....

Related articles

P0073 OBD-II Trouble Code: Ambient Air Temperature Sensor Circuit High input
P0073 code definition Ambient Air Temperature Sensor Circuit High input Depending on the type of vehicle these are some related OBD-II Diagnostic...
P0184 OBD-II Trouble Code: Fuel Temperature Sensor "A" Circuit Intermittent
P0184 P0184 trouble code definition Fuel Temperature Sensor "A" Circuit Intermittent What the P0184 code means P0184 is a generic OBD-II code indicating that the fuel temperature sensor A is intermittent; either the sensor input is not steady and goes...
P0626 OBD-II Trouble Code: Generator Field/F Terminal Circuit High
P0626 means there's a fault on the generator field circuit due to a faulty alternator, battery, wiring, or poor communication between control module.